Clasification Society Rulefinder 2020 - Version 9.33 - Fix
Common Structural Rules - Common Structural Rules for Bulk Carriers and Oil Tankers, January 2019 - Part 1 General Hull Requirements - Chapter 8 Buckling - Section 5 Buckling Capacity - 2 Buckling Capacity of Plates and Stiffeners

2 Buckling Capacity of Plates and Stiffeners

2.1 Overall stiffened panel capacity

2.1.1 The elastic stiffened panel limit state is based on the following interaction formula:

where cf and Pz are defined in [2.3.4].

2.2 Plate capacity

2.2.1 Plate limit state The plate limit state is based on the following interaction formulae:

with

γc = minc1c2c3c4)

where:

σx , σy : Applied normal stress to the plate panel, in N/mm2, to be taken as defined in [2.2.7].

τ : Applied shear stress to the plate panel, in N/mm2.

σcx’ : Ultimate buckling stress, in N/mm2, in direction parallel to the longer edge of the buckling panel as defined in [2.2.3].

σcy’ : Ultimate buckling stress, in N/mm2, in direction parallel to the shorter edge of the buckling panel as defined in [2.2.3].

τc’ : Ultimate buckling shear stresses, in N/mm2, as defined in [2.2.3].

γc1, γc2, γc3, γc4: Stress multiplier factors at failure for each of the above different limit states. γc2 and γc3 are only to be considered when σx ≥ 0 and σy ≥ 0 respectively.

B : Coefficient given in Table 1.

e0 : Coefficient given in Table 1.

βp : Plate slenderness parameter taken as:

Table 1 : Definition of coefficients B and e0

Applied Stress B e0
σx≥ 0 and σy≥ 0 0.7−0.3 βp2

σx< 0 or σy< 0 1.0 2.0

2.2.2 Reference degree of slenderness

The reference degree of slenderness is to be taken as:

where:

K : Buckling factor, as defined in Table 3 and Table 4.

2.2.3 Ultimate buckling stresses

The ultimate buckling stresses of plate panels, in N/mm2, are to be taken as:

σcx’ = Cx ReH_P

σcy’ = Cy ReH_P

The ultimate buckling stress of plate panels subject to shear, in N/mm2, is to be taken as:

where:

Cx, Cy, Cτ : Reduction factors, as defined in Table 3.
  • For the 1st Equation of [2.2.1], when σx < 0 or σy < 0, the reduction factors are to taken as:

    Cx= Cy = Cτ = 1.

  • For the other cases:
    • For SP-A and UP-A, Cy is calculated according to Table 3 by using

    • For SP-B and UP-B, Cy is calculated according to Table 3 by using

      c1 = 1

    • For vertically stiffened single side skin of bulk carrier, Cy is calculated according to Table 3 by using

    • For corrugation of corrugated bulkheads, Cy is calculated according to Table 3 by using

The boundary conditions for plates are to be considered as simply supported, see cases 1, 2 and 15 of Table 3. If the boundary conditions differ significantly from simple support, a more appropriate boundary condition can be applied according to the different cases of Table 3 subject to the agreement of the Society.

2.2.4 Correction factor Flong

The correction factor Flong depending on the edge stiffener types on the longer side of the buckling panel is defined in Table 2. An average value of Flong is to be used for plate panels having different edge stiffeners. For stiffener types other than those mentioned in Table 2, the value of c is to be agreed by the Society. In such a case, value of c higher than those mentioned in Table 2 can be used, provided it is verified by buckling strength check of panel using non-linear FE analysis and deemed appropriate by the Society.

Table 2 : Correction factor Flong

Structural element types Flong c
Unstiffened Panel 1.0 N/A
Stiffened Panel Stiffener not fixed at both ends 1.0 N/A
Stiffener fixed at both ends Flat bar (1)

0.10
Bulb profile 0.30
Angle, L2 and L3 profiles 0.40
T profile 0.30
Girder of high rigidity (e.g. bottom transverse) 1.4 N/A
U type profile fitted on hatch cover (2)
  • Plate on which the U type profile is fitted
    • For b2 < b1 : Flong = 1
    • For b2b1 :
  • Other plate of the U type profile: Flong = 1
0.2

(1) tw is the net web thickness, in mm, without the correction defined in [2.3.2].

(2) b1 and b2 are defined in Pt 2, Ch 1, Sec 5, Figure 1.

2.2.5 Correction factor Ftran

The correction factor Ftran is to be taken as:
  • For transversely framed EPP of single side skin bulk carrier, between the hopper and top wing tank:
    • Ftran = 1.25 when the two adjacent frames are supported by one tripping bracket fitted in way of the adjacent plate panels.
    • Ftran = 1.33 when the two adjacent frames are supported by two tripping brackets each fitted in way of the adjacent plate panels.
    • Ftran = 1.15 elsewhere.
  • For other cases: Ftran = 1

2.2.6 Curved plate panels

This requirement for curved plate limit state is applicable when R/tp ≤ 2500. Otherwise, the requirement for plate limit state given in [2.2.1] is applicable.

The curved plate limit state is based on the following interaction formula:

where:

σax : Applied axial stress to the cylinder corresponding to the curved plate panel, in N/mm2. In case of tensile axial stresses, σax = 0.

σtg : Applied tangential stress to the cylinder corresponding to the curved plate panel, in N/mm2. In case of tensile tangential stresses, σtg = 0.

Cax, Ctg, Cτ : Buckling reduction factor of the curved plate panel, as defined in Table 4.

The stress multiplier factor, γc, of the curved plate panel need not be taken less than the stress multiplier factor, γc, for the expanded plane panel according to [2.2.1].

Table 3 : Buckling factor and reduction factor for plane plate panels

Case Stress ratio ψ Aspect ratio α Buckling factor K Reduction factor C

1

1 ≥ ψ ≥ 0

When σx ≤ 0:

Cx = 1

When σx > 0:

Cx = 1 for λ ≤ λc

where:

c = (1.25 – 0.12ψ) ≤ 1.25

0 > ψ > –1 Kx = Flong [7.63 – ψ (6.26 – 10ψ)]
ψ ≤ –1 Kx = Flong [5.975(1 – ψ)2]

2

1 ≥ ψ ≥ 0

When σy ≤ 0:

Cy = 1

When σy > 0:

where:

c = (1.25 – 0.12ψ) ≤ 1.25

R = λ(1 – λ ⁄ c ) for λ < λc

R = 0.22 for λ ≥ λc

c1 as defined in [2.2.3]

α ≤ 6 f1 = (1 – ψ)(α – 1)
α > 6

but not greater than

α > 6(1 – ψ)

but not greater than14.5 – 0.35β2

f2 = f3 = 0

3 (1 – ψ) ≤ α ≤ 6(1 – ψ)

f2 = f3 = 0

1.5(1 – ψ) ≤ α < 3(1 – ψ)

f2 = f3 = 0

1 – ψ ≤ α < 1.5(1 – ψ)
  • For α > 1.5:

    f2 = 3β – 2

    f3 = 0

  • For α ≤ 1.5:

    f3 = 0

f4 = (1.5 – Min(1.5;α))2

0.75(1 – ψ) ≤ α < 1 – ψ

f1 = 0

f4 = (1.5 – Min(1.5;α))2

where:

3

1 ≥ ψ ≥ 0

Cx = 1 for λ ≤ 0.7

0 > ψ ≥ –1

4

1 ≥ ψ ≥ –1

5

α ≥ 1.64 Kx = 1.28
α < 1.64

6

1 ≥ ψ ≥ 0

Cy = 1 for λ ≤ 0.7

0 > ψ ≥ –1

7

1 ≥ ψ ≥ –1

8

9

Kx = 6.97

Cx = 1 for λ ≤ 0.83

for λ > 0.83

10

Cy = 1 for λ ≤ 0.83

for λ > 0.83

11

α ≥ 4 Kx = 4

Cx = 1 for λ ≤ 0.83

for λ > 0.83

α < 4

12

Ky = Ky determined as per case 2

For α < 2:

Cy = Cy2

For α ≥ 2:

where:

Cy2 : Cy determined as per case 2

13

α ≥ 4 Kx = 6.97

Cx = 1 for λ ≤ 0.83

for λ > 0.83

α < 4

14

Cy = 1 for λ ≤ 0.83

for λ > 0.83

15

Cτ = 1 for λ ≤ 0.84

16

17

Kτ = Kτ case15 r

Kτ case15: Kτ according to case 15

r : opening reduction factor taken as:
  • with

18

 

Cτ = 1 for λ ≤ 0.84

19

  Kτ = 8

Edge boundary conditions:

Note 1: Cases listed are general cases. Each stress component ( σx, σy) is to be understood in local coordinates.

Table 4 : Buckling and reduction factor for curved plate panel with R/tp ≤ 2500

Case Aspect ratio Buckling factor K Reduction factor C

1

For general application:
  • Cax = 1 for λ ≤ 0.25
  • Cax = 1.233 – 0.933λ for 0.25 < λ ≤ 1
  • Cax = 0.3 ⁄ λ3 for 1 < λ ≤ 1.5
  • Cax = 0.2 ⁄ λ2 for λ > 1.5
For curved single fields, e.g. bilge strake, which are bounded by plane panels as shown in Ch 6, Sec 4, Figure 1:

2a

2b

For general application:
  • Ctg = 1 for λ ≤ 0.4
  • Ctg = 1.274 – 0.686λ for 0.4 < λ ≤ 1.2
For curved single fields, e.g. bilge strake, which are bounded by plane panels as shown in Ch 6, Sec 4, Figure 1:

3

As in load case 2a.

4

Cτ = 1 for λ ≤ 0.4

Cτ = 1.274 – 0.686λ for 0.4 < λ ≤ 1.2

Explanations for boundary conditions:

2.2.7 Applied normal stress to plate panel

The normal stress, σx and σy, in N/mm2, to be applied for the plate panel capacity calculation as given in [2.2.1] are to be taken as follows:
  • For FE analysis, the reference stresses as defined in Ch 8, Sec 4, [2.4].
  • For prescriptive assessment, the axial or transverse compressive stresses calculated according to Ch 8, Sec 3, [2.2.1], at load calculation points of the considered elementary plate panel, as defined in Ch 3, Sec 7, [2].
  • For grillage analysis where the stresses are obtained based on beam theory, the stresses taken as:

  • where:
  • σxb, σyb : Stress, in N/mm2, from grillage beam analysis respectively along x or y axis of the attached buckling panel.
The shear stress τ, in N/mm2, to be applied for the plate panel capacity calculation as given in [2.2.1] are to be taken as follows:
  • For FE analysis, the reference shear stresses as defined in Ch 8, Sec 4, [2.4].
  • For prescriptive assessment, the shear stresses calculated according to Ch 8, Sec 3, [2.2.1], at load calculation points of the considered elementary plate panel, as defined in Ch 3, Sec 7, [2].
  • For grillage beam analysis, τ = 0 in the attached buckling panel.

2.3 Stiffeners

2.3.1 Buckling modes

The following buckling modes are to be checked:
  • Stiffener induced failure (SI).
  • Associated plate induced failure (PI).

2.3.2 Web thickness of flat bar

For accounting the decrease of the stiffness due to local lateral deformation, the effective web thickness of flat bar stiffener, in mm, is to be used in [2.3.4] for the calculation of the net sectional area, As, the net section modulus, Z, and the moment of inertia, I, of the stiffener and is taken as:

2.3.3 Idealisation of bulb profile

Bulb profiles are to be considered as equivalent angle profiles, as defined in Ch 3, Sec 7, [1.4.1].

2.3.4 Ultimate buckling capacity

When σa + σb + σw > 0, the ultimate buckling capacity for stiffeners is to be checked according to the following interaction formula:

where:

σa : Effective axial stress, in N/mm2, at mid span of the stiffener, acting on the stiffener with its attached plating.

σx : Nominal axial stress, in N/mm2, acting on the stiffener with its attached plating.
  • For FE analysis, σx is the FE corrected stress as defined in [2.3.6] in the attached plating in the direction of the stiffener axis.
  • For prescriptive assessment, σx is the axial stress calculated according to Ch 8, Sec 3, [2.2.1] at load calculation point of the stiffener, as defined in Ch 3, Sec 7, [3].
  • For grillage beam analysis, σx is the stress acting along the x-axis of the attached buckling panel.
ReH : Specified minimum yield stress of the material, in N/mm2:
  • ReH = ReH_S for stiffener induced failure (SI).
  • ReH = ReH_P for plate induced failure (PI).
σb : Bending stress in the stiffener, in N/mm2:
Z : Net section modulus of stiffener, in cm3, including effective width of plating according to [2.3.5], to be taken as:
  • The section modulus calculated at the top of stiffener flange for stiffener induced failure (SI).
  • The section modulus calculated at the attached plating for plate induced failure (PI).
CPI : Plate induced failure pressure coefficient:
  • CPI = 1 if the lateral pressure is applied on the side opposite to the stiffener.
  • CPI = -1 if the lateral pressure is applied on the same side as the stiffener.
CSI : Stiffener induced failure pressure coefficient:
  • CSI = -1 if the lateral pressure is applied on the side opposite to the stiffener.
  • CSI = 1 if the lateral pressure is applied on the same side as the stiffener.
M1 : Bending moment, in Nmm, due to the lateral load P:
  • for continuous stiffener
  • for sniped stiffener
  • for stiffener sniped at one end and continuous at the other end
P : Lateral load, in kN/m0.
  • For FE analysis, P is the average pressure as defined in Ch 8, Sec 4, [2.5.2] in the attached plating.
  • For prescriptive assessment, P is the pressure calculated at load calculation point of the stiffener, as defined in Ch 3, Sec 7, [3].
Ci : Pressure coefficient:
  • Ci = CSI for stiffener induced failure (SI).
  • Ci = CPI for plate induced failure (PI).
M0 : Bending moment, in Nmm, due to the lateral deformation w of stiffener:
FE : Ideal elastic buckling force of the stiffener, in N.
I : Moment of inertia, in cm4, of the stiffener including effective width of attached plating according to [2.3.5]. I is to comply with the following requirement:
tp : Net thickness of plate, in mm, to be taken as
  • For prescriptive requirements: the mean thickness of the two attached plating panels,
  • For FE analysis: the thickness of the considered EPP on one side of the stiffener.
Pz : Nominal lateral load, in N/mm2, acting on the stiffener due to stresses, σx, σy and τ, in the attached plating in way of the stiffener mid span:
  • but not less than 0
  • but not less than 0
σy : Stress applied on the edge along y axis of the buckling panel, in N/mm2, but not less than 0.
  • For FE analysis, σy is the FE corrected stress as defined in [2.3.6] in the attached plating in the direction perpendicular to the stiffener axis.
  • For prescriptive assessment, σy is the maximum compressive stress calculated according to Ch 8, Sec 3, [2.2.1], at load calculation points of the stiffener attached plating, as defined in Ch 3, Sec 7, [2].
  • For grillage beam analysis, σy is the stress acting along the y-axis of the attached buckling panel.
τ : Applied shear stress, in N/mm2.
  • For FE analysis, τ is the reference shear stress as defined in Ch 8, Sec 4, [2.4.2] in the attached plating.
  • For prescriptive assessment, τ is the shear stress at the attached plate calculated according to Ch 8, sec 3, [2.2.1] at the following load calculation point:
    • At the middle of the full span, l, of the considered stiffener
    • At the intersection point between the stiffener and its attached plate.
  • For grillage beam analysis, τ = 0 in the attached buckling panel.
m1, m2 : Coefficients taken equal to:
  • m1 = 1.47, m2 = 0.49 for α ≥ 2
  • m1 = 1.96, m2 = 0.37 for α < 2
c : Factor taking into account the stresses in the attached plating acting perpendicular to the stiffener’s axis:
  • c = 0.5(1 + ψ) for 0 ≤ ψ ≤ 1

ψ : Edge stress ratio for case 2 according to Table 3.

w : Deformation of stiffener, in mm:
  • w = w0 + w1
w0 : Assumed imperfection, in mm, to be taken as:
  • w0 = /1000 in general.
  • w0 = –wna for stiffeners sniped at one or both ends considering stiffener induced failure (SI).
  • w0 = wna for stiffeners sniped at one or both ends considering plate induced failure (PI).

wna: : Distance from the mid-point of attached plating to the neutral axis of the stiffener calculated with the effective width of the attached plating according to [2.3.5].

w1 : Deformation of stiffener, in mm, at mid-point of stiffener span due to lateral load P. In case of uniformly distributed load, w1 is to be taken as:
  • in general
  • for stiffeners sniped at both ends
  • for stiffeners sniped at one end and continuous at the other end.
cf : Elastic support provided by the stiffener, in N/mm2:
cxa : Coefficient to be taken as:
σw : Stress due to torsional deformation, in N/mm2, to be taken as:
  • for stiffener induced failure (SI).
  • σw = 0 for plate induced failure (PI).
yw : Distance, in mm, from centroid of stiffener cross section to the free edge of stiffener flange, to be taken as:
  • for flat bar.
  • for angle and bulb profiles.
  • for L2 profile
  • for L3 profile
  • for T profile.
Φ0 : Coefficient taken as:
σET : Reference stress for torsional buckling, in N/mm2:

IP : Net polar moment of inertia of the stiffener, in cm4, about point C as shown in Figure 1, as defined in Table 5.

IT : Net St. Venant’s moment of inertia of the stiffener, in cm4, as defined in Table 5.

Iω : Net sectional moment of inertia of the stiffener, in cm6, about point C as shown in Figure 1, as defined in Table 5.

ε : Degree of fixation.

Aw : Net web area, in mm2.

Af : Net flange area, in mm2.

Table 5 : Moments of inertia

  Flat bars (1) Bulb, angle, L2, L3 and T profiles
IP
IT
Iω

for bulb, angle, L2 and L3 profiles.

for T profiles.

(1) tw is the net web thickness, in mm. tw_red as defined in [2.3.2] is not to be used in this table.

2.3.5 Effective width of attached plating

The effective width of attached plating of stiffeners, beff, in mm, is to be taken as:
  • For σx > 0:
    • For FE analysis,

      beff = min (Cx b, χs s)

    • For prescriptive assessment,

  • For σx ≤ 0:
    • beff = χs s

where:

χs : Effective width coefficient to be taken as:
: Effective length of the stiffener, in mm, taken as:
  • for stiffener fixed at both ends.
  • for stiffener simply supported at one end and fixed at the other.
  • for stiffener simply supported at both ends.

2.3.6 FE corrected stresses for stiffener capacity

When the reference stresses σx and σy obtained by FE analysis according to Ch 8, Sec 4, [2.4] are both compressive, they are to be corrected according to the following formulae:
  • If σx < νσy :

    σxcor = 0

    σycor = σy

  • If σy < νσx :

    σxcor = σx

    σycor = 0

  • In the other cases:

    σxcor = σx – νσy

    σycor = σy – νσx

2.4 Primary supporting members

2.4.1 Web plate in way of openings

The web plate of primary supporting members with openings is to be assessed for buckling based on the combined axial compressive and shear stresses.

The web plate adjacent to the opening on both sides is to be considered as individual unstiffened plate panels as shown in Table 6.

The interaction formulae of [2.2.1] are to be used with:
  • σx = σav
  • σy = 0
  • τ = τav

where:

σav : Weighted average compressive stress, in N/mm2, in the area of web plate being considered, i.e. P1, P2 or P3 as shown in Table 6. For the application of the Table 6, the weighted average shear stress is to be taken as:
  • Opening modelled in primary supporting members:

    τav : Weighted average shear stress, in N/mm2, in the area of web plate being considered, i.e. P1, P2 or P3 as shown in Table 6.

  • Opening not modelled in primary supporting members:

    τav : Weighted average shear stress, in N/mm2, given in Table 6.

2.4.2 Reduction factors of web plate in way of openings

The reduction factors, Cx or Cy in combination with, Cτ of the plate panel(s) of the web adjacent to the opening is to be taken as shown in Table 6.

2.4.3 The equivalent plate panel of web plate of primary supporting members crossed by perpendicular stiffeners is to be idealised as shown in Figure 2.

Figure 2 : Web plate idealisation

The correction of panel breadth is applicable also for other slot configurations provided that the web or collar plate is attached to at least one side of the passing stiffener.

Table 6 : Reduction factors

Configuration Cx, Cy Cτ
Opening modelled in PSM

Opening not modelled in PSM

(a) Without edge reinforcements:

Separate reduction factors are to be applied to areas P1 and P2 using case 3 or case 6 in Table 3, with edge stress ratio:

ψ = 1.0

Separate reduction factors are to be applied to areas P1 and P2 using case 18 or case 19 in Table 3.

When case 17 of Table 3 is applicable: A common reduction factor is to be applied to areas P1 and P2 using case 17 in Table 3 with:

τav = τav(web)

When case 17 of Table 3 is not applicable: Separate reduction factors are to be applied to areas P1 and P2 using case 18 or case 19 in Table 3 with:

τav = τav(web) h/(h − h0)

(b) With edge reinforcements:

Separate reduction factors are to be applied for areas P1 and P2 using Cx for case 1 or Cy for case 2 in Table 3 with stress ratio:

ψ = 1.0

Separate reduction factors are to be applied for areas P1 and P2 using case 15 in Table 3.

Separate reduction factors are to be applied to areas P1 and P2 using case 15 in Table 3 with:

τav = τav (web) h/(h − h0)

(c) Example of hole in web:

Panels P1 and P2 are to be evaluated in accordance with (a). Panel P3 is to be evaluated in accordance with (b).

Where:

h : Height, in m, of the web of the primary supporting member in way of the opening.

h0 : Height, in m, of the opening measured in the depth of the web.

τav(web) : Weighted average shear stress, in N/mm2 overthe web height hof the primary supporting member.

Note 1: Web panels to be considered for buckling in way of openings are shown shaded and numbered P1, P2, etc.


Copyright 2020 Clasification Society, International Maritime Organization, International Labour Organization or Maritime and Coastguard Agency. All rights reserved. Clasification Society, its affiliates and subsidiaries and their respective officers, employees or agents are, individually and collectively, referred to in this clause as 'Clasification Society'. Clasification Society Register assumes no responsibility and shall not be liable to any person for any loss, damage or expense caused by reliance on the information or advice in this document or howsoever provided, unless that person has signed a contract with the relevant Clasification Society entity for the provision of this information or advice and in that case any responsibility or liability is exclusively on the terms and conditions set out in that contract.