16 Manufacture, Workmanship and Testing
Clasification Society 2024 - Version 9.40
Clasifications Register Rules and Regulations - Rules and Regulations for the Classification of Ships using Gases or other Low-flashpoint Fuels, July 2022 - Part B-1 - Part B-1 - 16 Manufacture, Workmanship and Testing

16 Manufacture, Workmanship and Testing

16.1 General

16.1.1 The manufacture, testing, inspection and documentation shall be in accordance with recognized standards and the regulations given in this Code.

LR 16.1-01 The manufacture, testing, inspection and certification are to be in accordance with the requirements of the Rules for the Manufacture, Testing and Certification of Materials (hereinafter referred to as the Rules for Materials).

16.1.2 Where post-weld heat treatment is specified or required, the properties of the base material shall be determined in the heat treated condition, in accordance with the applicable tables of chapter 7, and the weld properties shall be determined in the heat treated condition in accordance with 16.3. In cases where a post-weld heat treatment is applied, the test regulations may be modified at the discretion of the Administration.

LR 16.1-02 A relaxation in the requirements for Charpy V-notch impact tests will be permitted for smaller fuel tanks or process pressure vessels which are post-weld heat treated. The extent of this relaxation will be specially considered for each application and will depend on the grade of steel and thickness involved.

16.2 General test regulations and specifications

16.2.1 Tensile test

16.2.1.1 Tensile testing shall be carried out in accordance with recognized standards.

16.2.1.2 Tensile strength, yield stress and elongation shall be to the satisfaction of the Administration. For carbon-manganese steel and other materials with definitive yield points, consideration shall be given to the limitation of the yield to tensile ratio.

LR 16.2-01 The grades of materials used are to generally have mechanical properties complying with the appropriate requirements as given in the Rules for Materials. Provided that the material has satisfactory ductility, there will be no limitation on the yield to tensile stress ratio, except for carbon–manganese steel grades for low temperature service. For carbon–manganese steel grades for low temperature service, the yield to tensile ratio requirement of Ch 3, 6 Ferritic steels for low temperature service of the Rules for the Manufacture, Testing and Certification of Materials is to be met.

16.2.2 Toughness test

16.2.2.1 Acceptance tests for metallic materials shall include Charpy V-notch toughness tests unless otherwise specified by the Administration. The specified Charpy V-notch regulations are minimum average energy values for three full size (10 mm × 10 mm) specimens and minimum single energy values for individual specimens. Dimensions and tolerances of Charpy V-notch specimens shall be in accordance with recognized standards. The testing and regulations for specimens smaller than 5.0 mm in size shall be in accordance with recognized standards. Minimum average values for sub-sized specimens shall be:

Charpy V-notch specimen size (mm) Minimum average energy of three specimens
10 x 10 KV
10 x 7.5 5/6 KV
10 x 5.0 2/3 KV
  • where:
  • KV = the energy values (J) specified in tables 7.1 to 7.4.

Only one individual value may be below the specified average value, provided it is not less than 70% of that value.

16.2.2.2 For base metal, the largest size Charpy V-notch specimens possible for the material thickness shall be machined with the specimens located as near as practicable to a point midway between the surface and the centre of the thickness and the length of the notch perpendicular to the surface as shown in figure 16.1.

Figure 16.1 – Orientation of base metal test specimen

16.2.2.3 For a weld test specimen, the largest size Charpy V-notch specimens possible for the material thickness shall be machined, with the specimens located as near as practicable to a point midway between the surface and the centre of the thickness. In all cases the distance from the surface of the material to the edge of the specimen shall be approximately 1 mm or greater. In addition, for double-V butt welds, specimens shall be machined closer to the surface of the second welded section. The specimens shall be taken generally at each of the following locations, as shown in figure 16.2, on the centreline of the welds, the fusion line and 1 mm, 3 mm and 5 mm from the fusion line.

Figure 16.2 – Orientation of weld test specimen

Notch locations in figure 16.2:

  • .1 centreline of the weld;
  • .2 on fusion line;
  • .3 in heat-affected zone (HAZ), 1 mm from fusion line;
  • .4 in HAZ, 3 mm from fusion line; and
  • .5 in HAZ, 5 mm from fusion line.

16.2.2.4 If the average value of the three initial Charpy V-notch specimens fails to meet the stated regulations, or the value for more than one specimen is below the required average value, or when the value for one specimen is below the minimum value permitted for a single specimen, three additional specimens from the same material may be tested and the results combined with those previously obtained to form a new average. If this new average complies with the regulations and if no more than two individual results are lower, than the required average and no more than one result is lower than the required value for a single specimen, the piece or batch may be accepted.

LR 16.2-02 Material toughness is to be determined by the Charpy V-notch impact test in accordance with the Rules for the Manufacture, Testing and Certification of Materials. In addition, LR may also request other types of tests, such as drop weight or crack tip opening displacement test. When required by Ch 3, 6.1 Scope 6.1.4 of the Rules for the Manufacture, Testing and Certification of Materials, an additional set of Charpy V-notch specimens with axes located on the centreline of thickness of the plate is required.

16.2.3 Bend test

16.2.3.1 The bend test may be omitted as a material acceptance test, but is required for weld tests. Where a bend test is performed, this shall be done in accordance with recognized standards.

LR 16.2-03 Bend tests are to be taken only when such tests are required in the Rules for Materials.

16.2.3.2 The bend tests shall be transverse bend tests, which may be face, root or side bends at the discretion of the Administration. However, longitudinal bend tests may be required in lieu of transverse bend tests in cases where the base material and weld metal have different strength levels.

16.2.4 Section observation and other testing

Macrosection, microsection observations and hardness tests may also be required by the Administration, and they shall be carried out in accordance with recognized standards, where required.

LR 16.2-04 These tests are to be carried out when required by the Rules for Materials and when required according to the scope of approval of the fuel containment system.

16.3 Welding of metallic materials and non-destructive testing for the fuel containment system

LR 16.3-01 Unless otherwise specified below, all welded construction is to be in accordance with Chapter 13 of the Rules for Materials.

LR 16.3-02 Unless otherwise specified in these Rules, welding procedure tests are to be performed in accordance with the requirements of Chapter 12 of the Rules for Materials. Generally, impact tests from aluminium welded joint are not required. For austenitic stainless steel welded joint, impact tests are not required from the heat affected zone.

16.3.1 General

This section shall apply to primary and secondary barriers only, including the inner hull where this forms the secondary barrier. Acceptance testing is specified for carbon, carbon-manganese, nickel alloy and stainless steels, but these tests may be adapted for other materials. At the discretion of the Administration, impact testing of stainless steel and aluminium alloy weldments may be omitted and other tests may be specially required for any material.

16.3.2 Welding consumables

Consumables intended for welding of fuel tanks shall be in accordance with recognized standards. Deposited weld metal tests and butt weld tests shall be required for all consumables. The results obtained from tensile and Charpy V-notch impact tests shall be in accordance with recognized standards. The chemical composition of the deposited weld metal shall be recorded for information.

LR 16.3-03 Welding consumables are to be approved by LR in accordance with Chapter 11 of the Rules for Materials.

16.3.3 Welding procedure tests for fuel tanks and process pressure vessels

16.3.3.1 Welding procedure tests for fuel tanks and process pressure vessels are required for all butt welds.

16.3.3.2 The test assemblies shall be representative of:

  • .1 each base material;

  • .2 each type of consumable and welding process; and

  • .3 each welding position.

16.3.3.3 For butt welds in plates, the test assemblies shall be so prepared that the rolling direction is parallel to the direction of welding. The range of thickness qualified by each welding procedure test shall be in accordance with recognized standards. Radiographic or ultrasonic testing may be performed at the option of the fabricator.

LR 16.3-04 Welding procedure tests are to be performed in accordance with the requirements of Chapter 12 of the Rules for Materials, except where indicated otherwise in these Rules. Mechanical tests for butt welds are to be in accordance with 16.3.3.4.

16.3.3.4 The following welding procedure tests for fuel tanks and process pressure vessels shall be done in accordance with 16.2 with specimens made from each test assembly:

  • .1 cross-weld tensile tests;

  • .2 longitudinal all-weld testing where required by the recognized standards;

  • .3 transverse bend tests, which may be face, root or side bends. However, longitudinal bend tests may be required in lieu of transverse bend tests in cases where the base material and weld metal have different strength levels;

  • .4 one set of three Charpy V-notch impacts, generally at each of the following locations, as shown in figure 16.2:

    • .1 centreline of the welds;

    • .2 fusion line;

    • .3 1 mm from the fusion line;

    • .4 3 mm from the fusion line; and

    • .5 5 mm from the fusion line;

  • .5 macrosection, microsection and hardness survey may also be required.

LR 16.3-05 Additionally, an all-weld metal tensile test is required from welding procedure tests for Type C independent fuel tanks. A macrosection and hardness survey is required for all welding procedure tests, except that the hardness survey is not required for austenitic stainless steel. Generally, microsections are not required.

LR 16.3-06 For alloys where the weld metal has a lower tensile strength than that of the parent metal, and such an application has prior approval by LR, the transverse weld tensile strength is not to be less than the specified design tensile strength.

16.3.3.5 Each test shall satisfy the following:

  • .1 tensile tests: cross-weld tensile strength is not to be less than the specified minimum tensile strength for the appropriate parent materials. For aluminium alloys, reference shall be made to 6.4.12.1.1.3 with regard to the regulations for weld metal strength of under-matched welds (where the weld metal has a lower tensile strength than the parent metal). In every case, the position of fracture shall be recorded for information;

  • .2 bend tests: no fracture is acceptable after a 180° bend over a former of a diameter four times the thickness of the test pieces; and

  • .3 Charpy V-notch impact tests: Charpy V-notch tests shall be conducted at the temperature prescribed for the base material being joined. The results of weld metal impact tests, minimum average energy (KV), shall be no less than 27 J. The weld metal regulations for sub-size specimens and single energy values shall be in accordance with 16.2.2. The results of fusion line and heat affected zone impact tests shall show a minimum average energy (KV) in accordance with the transverse or longitudinal regulations of the base material, whichever is applicable, and for sub-size specimens, the minimum average energy (KV) shall be in accordance with 16.2.2. If the material thickness does not permit machining either full-size or standard sub-size specimens, the testing procedure and acceptance standards shall be in accordance with recognized standards.

LR 16.3-07 For aluminium alloys, the bend test required in 16.3.3.4.3 is to be carried out over a former with D/t according to Ch 12,4 of the Rules for Materials.

LR 16.3-08 Bend tests revealing small openings up to a maximum of 3 mm in any direction are acceptable.

16.3.3.6 Procedure tests for fillet welding shall be in accordance with recognized standards. In such cases, consumables shall be so selected that exhibit satisfactory impact properties.

LR 16.3-09 Ch 12 of the Rules for Materials is to be followed for procedure tests for fillet welding, and LR approved welding consumables are to be used.

16.3.4 Welding procedure tests for piping

Welding procedure tests for piping shall be carried out and shall be similar to those detailed for fuel tanks in 16.3.3.

16.3.5 Production weld tests

16.3.5.1 For all fuel tanks and process pressure vessels except membrane tanks, production weld tests shall generally be performed for approximately each 50 m of butt-weld joints and shall be representative of each welding position. For secondary barriers, the same type production tests as required for primary tanks shall be performed, except that the number of tests may be reduced subject to agreement with the Administration. Tests, other than those specified in 16.3.5.2 to 16.3.5.5 may be required for fuel tanks or secondary barriers.

16.3.5.2 The production tests for types A and B independent tanks shall include bend tests and, where required for procedure tests, one set of three Charpy V-notch tests. The tests shall be made for each 50 m of weld. The Charpy V-notch tests shall be made with specimens having the notch alternately located in the centre of the weld and in the heat affected zone (most critical location based on procedure qualification results). For austenitic stainless steel, all notches shall be in the centre of the weld.

LR 16.3-10 The production weld tests shall satisfy the applicable requirements of 16.3.3.5.

16.3.5.3 For type C independent tanks and process pressure vessels, transverse weld tensile tests are required in addition to the tests listed in 16.3.5.2. Tensile tests shall meet regulation 16.3.3.5.

LR 16.3-11 In addition, an all-weld metal tensile test for Type C independent fuel tanks and Class 1 and Class 2/1 process pressure vessels is required.

LR 16.3-12 In addition, a macrosection examination and hardness survey are required according to Ch 13,4.8 of the Rules for Materials.

16.3.5.4 The quality assurance/quality control (QA/QC) program shall ensure the continued conformity of the production welds as defined in the material manufacturers quality manual (QM).

16.3.5.5 The test regulations for membrane tanks are the same as the applicable test regulations listed in 16.3.3.

LR 16.3-13 Requirements for production tests from membrane tanks are to be agreed with LR prior to manufacture.

LR 16.3-14 Unless otherwise stated below, all welds are to be subject to non-destructive examination in accordance with the requirements of Chapter 13 of the Rules for Materials.

16.3.6 Non-destructive testing

16.3.6.1 All test procedures and acceptance standards shall be in accordance with recognized standards, unless the designer specifies a higher standard in order to meet design assumptions. Radiographic testing shall be used in principle to detect internal defects. However, an approved ultrasonic test procedure in lieu of radiographic testing may be conducted, but in addition supplementary radiographic testing at selected locations shall be carried out to verify the results. Radiographic and ultrasonic testing records shall be retained.

16.3.6.2 For type A independent tanks where the design temperature is below -20°C, and for type B independent tanks, regardless of temperature, all full penetration butt welds of the shell plating of fuel tanks shall be subjected to non-destructive testing suitable to detect internal defects over their full length. Ultrasonic testing in lieu of radiographic testing may be carried out under the same conditions as described in 16.3.6.1.

16.3.6.3 In each case the remaining tank structure, including the welding of stiffeners and other fittings and attachments, shall be examined by magnetic particle or dye penetrant methods as considered necessary.

16.3.6.4 For type C independent tanks, the extent of non-destructive testing shall be total or partial according to recognized standards, but the controls to be carried out shall not be less than the following:

  • .1 Total non-destructive testing referred to in 6.4.15.3.2.1.3

    • Radiographic testing:

    • .1 all butt welds over their full length.
    • Non-destructive testing for surface crack detection:
    • .2 all welds over 10% of their length;
    • .3 reinforcement rings around holes, nozzles, etc. over their full length.
    • As an alternative, ultrasonic testing, as described in 16.3.6.1, may be accepted as a partial substitute for the radiographic testing. In addition, the Administration may require total ultrasonic testing on welding of reinforcement rings around holes, nozzles, etc.
  • .2 Partial non-destructive testing referred to in 6.4.15.3.2.1.3:

    • Radiographic testing:
    • .1 all butt welded crossing joints and at least 10% of the full length of butt welds at selected positions uniformly distributed.
    • Non-destructive testing for surface crack detection:
    • .2 reinforcement rings around holes, nozzles, etc. over their full length.
    • Ultrasonic testing:
    • .3 as may be required by the Administration in each instance.

LR 16.3-15 Non-destructive testing is to meet the requirements of Ch 13,4 of the Rules for Materials for Class 1 pressure vessels.

16.3.6.5 The quality assurance/quality control (QA/QC) program shall ensure the continued conformity of the non-destructive testing of welds, as defined in the material manufacturer's quality manual (QM).

16.3.6.6 Inspection of piping shall be carried out in accordance with the regulations of chapter 7.

16.3.6.7 The secondary barrier shall be non-destructive tested for internal defects as considered necessary. Where the outer shell of the hull is part of the secondary barrier, all sheer strake butts and the intersections of all butts and seams in the side shell shall be tested by radiographic testing.

16.4 Other regulations for construction in metallic materials

16.4.1 General

Inspection and non-destructive testing of welds shall be in accordance with regulations in 16.3.5 and 16.3.6. Where higher standards or tolerances are assumed in the design, they shall also be satisfied.

16.4.2 Independent tank

For type C tanks and type B tanks primarily constructed of bodies of revolution the tolerances relating to manufacture, such as out-of-roundness, local deviations from the true form, welded joints alignment and tapering of plates having different thicknesses, shall comply with recognized standards. The tolerances shall also be related to the buckling analysis referred to in 6.4.15.2.3.1 and 6.4.15.3.3.2.

LR 16.4-01 For Type C independent tanks, manufacture and workmanship are to satisfy the requirements of Ch 13,4 of the Rules for Materials for Class 1 pressure vessels.

LR 16.4-02 For Type C tanks of carbon and carbon-manganese steel with plate thickness up to 40 mm, post-weld heat treatment shall be performed after welding, if the design temperature is equal to or less than −10°C.

For Type C independent tanks with plate thickness up to 40 mm, if the design temperature is higher than −10°C, and for any other carbon and carbon-manganese tanks, the post-weld heat treatment is to conform to the requirements of Ch 13, 4.10 Post-weld heat treatment in the Rules for the Manufacture, Testing and Certification of Materials.

For Type C tanks of carbon and carbon-manganese steel with plate thickness greater than 40 mm and up to 50 mm, post-weld heat treatment shall be performed after welding. Any proposal for exemption of post-weld heat treatment is to be based on an alternative approach as approved by LR (e.g. Engineering Critical Assessment in accordance with BS7910 or an equivalent standard). Mechanical stress relieving as permitted under Ch 6, 6.6 Other requirements for construction in metallic materials 6.6.2.3 is not applicable for Type C tanks of carbon and carbon-manganese steel with plate thickness greater than 40 mm and up to 50 mm.

The requirements of Ch 13, 1.16 Post-weld heat treatment and Ch 13, 4.11 Basic requirements for post-weld heat treatment of fusion welded pressure vessels in the Rules for the Manufacture, Testing and Certification of Materials are to be followed for the method and technique of post-weld heat treatment.

16.4.3 Secondary barriers

During construction the regulations for testing and inspection of secondary barriers shall be approved or accepted by the Administration (see also 6.4.4.5 and 6.4.4.6).

16.4.4 Membrane tanks

The quality assurance/quality control (QA/QC) program shall ensure the continued conformity of the weld procedure qualification, design details, materials, construction, inspection and production testing of components. These standards and procedures shall be developed during the prototype testing programme.

16.5 Testing

16.5.1 Testing and inspections during construction

16.5.1.1 All liquefied gas fuel tanks and process pressure vessels shall be subjected to hydrostatic or hydro-pneumatic pressure testing in accordance with 16.5.2 to 16.5.5, as applicable for the tank type.

16.5.1.2 All tanks shall be subject to a tightness test which may be performed in combination with the pressure test referred to in 16.5.1.1.

16.5.1.3 The gas tightness of the fuel containment system with reference to 6.3.3 shall be tested.

16.5.1.4 Regulations with respect to inspection of secondary barriers shall be decided by the Administration in each case, taking into account the accessibility of the barrier (see also 6.4.4).

16.5.1.5 The Administration may require that for ships fitted with novel type B independent tanks, or tanks designed according to 6.4.16 at least one prototype tank and its support shall be instrumented with strain gauges or other suitable equipment to confirm stress levels during the testing required in 16.5.1.1. Similar instrumentation may be required for type C independent tanks, depending on their configuration and on the arrangement of their supports and attachments.

16.5.1.6 The overall performance of the fuel containment system shall be verified for compliance with the design parameters during the first LNG bunkering, when steady thermal conditions of the liquefied gas fuel are reached, in accordance with the requirements of the Administration. Records of the performance of the components and equipment, essential to verify the design parameters, shall be maintained on board and be available to the Administration.

LR 16.5-01 The overall performance of the fuel containment system is to be verified for compliance with the design parameters during initial trials. The initial trials are to be witnessed by LR’s Surveyors, and are to demonstrate that the system is capable of being inerted, cooled and bunkered in a satisfactory manner, and that all safety devices function correctly. The temperature at which these tests are carried out is to be at or near the minimum fuel temperature.

LR 16.5-02 Where refrigeration plant is fitted, or other means to control the fuel tank(s) vapour pressure, its operation is to be demonstrated to the Surveyors. Records of the plant performance taken during the first bunkered voyage at minimum temperature are to be submitted. The above tests may be carried out in conjunction with the vessel’s normal trading commitments. Normal voyage logs of plant performance are to be maintained for examination by the Surveyors when requested.

16.5.1.7 The fuel containment system shall be inspected for cold spots during or immediately following the first LNG bunkering, when steady thermal conditions are reached. Inspection of the integrity of thermal insulation surfaces that cannot be visually checked shall be carried out in accordance with the requirements of the Administration.

16.5.1.8 Heating arrangements, if fitted in accordance with 6.4.13.1.1.3 and 6.4.13.1.1.4, shall be tested for required heat output and heat distribution.

16.5.2 Type A independent tanks

All type A independent tanks shall be subjected to a hydrostatic or hydro-pneumatic pressure testing. This test shall be performed such that the stresses approximate, as far as practicable, the design stresses, and that the pressure at the top of the tank corresponds at least to the MARVS. When a hydropneumatic test is performed, the conditions shall simulate, as far as practicable, the design loading of the tank and of its support structure including dynamic components, while avoiding stress levels that could cause permanent deformation.

LR 16.5-03 If a hydropneumatic or a hydrostatic test is utilised, the test head of water and air pressure are to be specified by designers. Details and procedures of the hydropneumatic or hydrostatic test are to be submitted for approval.

LR 16.5-04 The scantlings of the tanks are to comply with LR 6.4-38,using equivalent internal pressure for the test condition.

LR 16.5-05 The primary structures of the tanks are to comply with Ch 2, 4.7 Tank test condition of the ShipRight Structural Design Assessment Procedure for Type A Tank Liquefied Gas Carriers and Ch 2, 4.7 Tank test condition of the ShipRight Structural Design Assessment Primary Hull and Cargo Tank Structure of Liquefied Gas Carriers Fitted with Type B Independent Tanks Primarily Constructed of Plane Surfaces for type A tanks and type B primarily constructed of plane surfaces tanks respectively. The designer may propose an alternative equivalent procedure subject to agreement with LR.

16.5.3 Type B independent tanks

Type B independent tanks shall be subjected to a hydrostatic or hydro-pneumatic pressure testing as follows:

  • .1 The test shall be performed as required in 16.5.2 for type A independent tanks.

  • .2 In addition, the maximum primary membrane stress or maximum bending stress in primary members under test conditions shall not exceed 90% of the yield strength of the material (as fabricated) at the test temperature. To ensure that this condition is satisfied, when calculations indicate that this stress exceeds 75% of the yield strength the test of the first of a series of identical tanks shall be monitored by the use of strain gauges or other suitable equipment.

16.5.4 Type C independent tanks and other pressure vessels

16.5.4.1 Each pressure vessel shall be subjected to a hydrostatic test at a pressure measured at the top of the tanks, of not less than 1.5 P0. In no case during the pressure test shall the calculated primary membrane stress at any point exceed 90% of the yield strength of the material at the test temperature. To ensure that this condition is satisfied where calculations indicate that this stress will exceed 0.75 times the yield strength, the test of the first of a series of identical tanks shall be monitored by the use of strain gauges or other suitable equipment in pressure vessels other than simple cylindrical and spherical pressure vessels.

16.5.4.2 The temperature of the water used for the test shall be at least 30°C above the nil-ductility transition temperature of the material, as fabricated.

16.5.4.3 The pressure shall be held for 2 hours per 25 mm of thickness, but in no case less than 2 hours.

16.5.4.4 Where necessary for liquefied gas fuel pressure vessels, a hydro-pneumatic test may be carried out under the conditions prescribed in 16.5.4.1 to 16.5.4.3.

LR 16.5-06 When a hydropneumatic test is performed, the conditions are to simulate, so far as practicable, the actual loading of the tank and its supports.

16.5.4.5 Special consideration may be given to the testing of tanks in which higher allowable stresses are used, depending on service temperature. However, regulation in 16.5.4.1 shall be fully complied with.

16.5.4.6 After completion and assembly, each pressure vessel and its related fittings shall be subjected to an adequate tightness test, which may be performed in combination with the pressure testing referred to in 16.5.4.1 or 16.5.4.4 as applicable.

16.5.4.7 Pneumatic testing of pressure vessels other than liquefied gas fuel tanks shall be considered on an individual case basis. Such testing shall only be permitted for those vessels designed or supported such that they cannot be safely filled with water, or for those vessels that cannot be dried and are to be used in a service where traces of the testing medium cannot be tolerated.

16.5.5 Membrane tanks

16.5.5.1 Design development testing

16.5.5.1.1 The design development testing required in 6.4.15.4.1.2 shall include a series of analytical and physical models of both the primary and secondary barriers, including corners and joints, tested to verify that they will withstand the expected combined strains due to static, dynamic and thermal loads at all filling levels. This will culminate in the construction of a prototype scaled model of the complete liquefied gas fuel containment system. Testing conditions considered in the analytical and physical model shall represent the most extreme service conditions the liquefied gas fuel containment system will be likely to encounter over its life. Proposed acceptance criteria for periodic testing of secondary barriers required in 6.4.4 may be based on the results of testing carried out on the prototype scaled model.

16.5.5.1.2 The fatigue performance of the membrane materials and representative welded or bonded joints in the membranes shall be determined by tests. The ultimate strength and fatigue performance of arrangements for securing the thermal insulation system to the hull structure shall be determined by analyses or tests.

16.5.5.2 Testing

  • .1 In ships fitted with membrane liquefied gas fuel containment systems, all tanks and other spaces that may normally contain liquid and are adjacent to the hull structure supporting the membrane, shall be hydrostatically tested.

  • .2 All hold structures supporting the membrane shall be tested for tightness before installation of the liquefied gas fuel containment system.

  • .3 Pipe tunnels and other compartments that do not normally contain liquid need not be hydrostatically tested.

16.6 Welding, post-weld heat treatment and non-destructive testing

16.6.1 General

Welding shall be carried out in accordance with 16.3.

16.6.2 Post-weld heat treatment

Post-weld heat treatment shall be required for all butt welds of pipes made with carbon, carbon-manganese and low alloy steels. The Administration may waive the regulations for thermal stress relieving of pipes with wall thickness less than 10 mm in relation to the design temperature and pressure of the piping system concerned.

LR 16.6-01 Post-weld heat treatment is required for all butt welds in pipes carrying natural gas contaminated with hydrogen sulphide which are constructed in steel with a minimum tensile strength exceeding 410 N/mm2.

LR 16.6-02 Unless otherwise stated below, all welds are to be subject to non-destructive examination in accordance with the requirements of Ch 13 of the Rules for Materials.

16.6.3 Non-destructive testing

In addition to normal controls before and during the welding, and to the visual inspection of the finished welds, as necessary for proving that the welding has been carried out correctly and according to the regulations in this paragraph, the following tests shall be required:

  • .1 100% radiographic or ultrasonic inspection of butt-welded joints for piping systems with;

    • .1 design temperatures colder than minus 10°C; or
    • .2 design pressure greater than 1.0 MPa; or
    • .3 gas supply pipes in ESD protected machinery spaces; or
    • .4 inside diameters of more than 75 mm; or
    • .5 wall thicknesses greater than 10 mm.
  • .2 When such butt welded joints of piping sections are made by automatic welding procedures approved by the Administration, then a progressive reduction in the extent of radiographic or ultrasonic inspection can be agreed, but in no case to less than 10% of each joint. If defects are revealed the extent of examination shall be increased to 100% and shall include inspection of previously accepted welds. This approval can only be granted if well-documented quality assurance procedures and records are available to assess the ability of the manufacturer to produce satisfactory welds consistently.

  • .3 The radiographic or ultrasonic inspection regulation may be reduced to 10% for butt-welded joints in the outer pipe of double-walled fuel piping.

  • .4 For other butt-welded joints of pipes not covered by 16.6.3.1 and 16.6.3.3, spot radiographic or ultrasonic inspection or other non-destructive tests shall be carried out depending upon service, position and materials. In general, at least 10% of butt-welded joints of pipes shall be subjected to radiographic or ultrasonic inspection.

LR 16.6-03 Non-destructive testing is to meet the requirements of Ch 13,5 of the Rules for Materials for pressure piping.

16.7 Testing regulations

16.7.1 Type testing of piping components

Valves

Each type of piping component intended to be used at a working temperature below minus 55°C shall be subject to the following type tests:

  • .1 Each size and type of valve shall be subjected to seat tightness testing over the full range of operating pressures and temperatures, at intervals, up to the rated design pressure of the valve. Allowable leakage rates shall be to the requirements of the Administration During the testing satisfactory operation of the valve shall be verified.

  • .2 The flow or capacity shall be certified to a recognized standard for each size and type of valve.

  • .3 Pressurized components shall be pressure tested to at least 1.5 times the design pressure.

  • .4 For emergency shutdown valves, with materials having melting temperatures lower than 925°C, the type testing shall include a fire test to a standard at least equivalent to those acceptable to the Organization.footnote

LR 16.7-01 For further details on the type testing of piping components, reference is to be made to LR 5.13-01, LR 5.13-02, LR 5.13-03 and LR 5.13-04 of the Rules and Regulations for the Construction and Classification of Ships for the Carriage of Liquefied Gases in Bulk, July 2019

16.7.2 Expansion bellows

The following type tests shall be performed on each type of expansion bellows intended for use on fuel piping outside the fuel tank as found acceptable in 7.3.6.4.3.1. and .3 and where required by the Administration, on those installed within the fuel tanks:

  • .1 Elements of the bellows, not pre-compressed, but axially restrained shall be pressure tested at not less than five times the design pressure without bursting. The duration of the test shall not be less than five minutes.

  • .2 A pressure test shall be performed on a type expansion joint, complete with all the accessories such as flanges, stays and articulations, at the minimum design temperature and twice the design pressure at the extreme displacement conditions recommended by the manufacturer without permanent deformation.

  • .3 A cyclic test (thermal movements) shall be performed on a complete expansion joint, which shall withstand at least as many cycles under the conditions of pressure, temperature, axial movement, rotational movement and transverse movement as it will encounter in actual service. Testing at ambient temperature is permitted when this testing is at least as severe as testing at the service temperature.

  • .4 A cyclic fatigue test (ship deformation, ship accelerations and pipe vibrations) shall be performed on a complete expansion joint, without internal pressure, by simulating the bellows movement corresponding to a compensated pipe length, for at least 2,000,000 cycles at a frequency not higher than 5 Hz. This test is only required when, due to the piping arrangement, ship deformation loads are actually experienced.

LR 16.7-02 For further details on the type testing of expansion bellows, reference is to be made to LR 5.13-05 and LR 5.13-06 of the Rules and Regulations for the Construction and Classification of Ships for the Carriage of Liquefied Gases in Bulk, July 2019

16.7.3 System testing regulations

16.7.3.1 The regulations for testing in this section apply to fuel piping inside and outside the fuel tanks. However, relaxation from these regulations for piping inside fuel tanks and open ended piping may be accepted by the Administration.

16.7.3.2 After assembly, all fuel piping shall be subjected to a strength test with a suitable fluid. The test pressure shall be at least 1.5 times the design pressure for liquid lines and 1.5 times the maximum system working pressure for vapour lines. When piping systems or parts of systems are completely manufactured and equipped with all fittings, the test may be conducted prior to installation on board the ship. Joints welded on board shall be tested to at least 1.5 times the design pressure.

16.7.3.3 After assembly on board, the fuel piping system shall be subjected to a leak test using air, or other suitable medium to a pressure depending on the leak detection method applied.

16.7.3.4 In double wall fuel piping systems the outer pipe or duct shall also be pressure tested to show that it can withstand the expected maximum pressure at pipe rupture.

LR 16.7-03 The pressure test required by 16.7.3.4 is to be carried out after assembly on board. Where this is not feasible, then consideration will be given to pressure testing of individual piping or ductwork prior to installation providing calculations verifying the design pressure of the ducting is submitted and the piping is satisfactorily leak tested after completion of installation.

16.7.3.5 All piping systems, including valves, fittings and associated equipment for handling fuel or vapours, shall be tested under normal operating conditions not later than at the first bunkering operation, in accordance with the requirements of the Administration.

LR 16.7-04 For gas fuel system with pressure no greater than 1 MPa, the gas fuel piping in the machinery space is to be tested in place by hydraulic pressure to 0,7 MPa or twice the working pressure, whichever is the greater. Subsequently, the lines are to be tested by air at the working pressure using soapy water, or equivalent, to verify that all joints are absolutely tight.

LR 16.7-05 For gas fuel systems with pressure greater than 1 MPa, all gas fuel piping shall be subjected to a strength test with a suitable fluid. The test pressure shall be at least 1,5 times the design pressure for liquid lines and 1,5 times the maximum system working pressure for vapour lines. When piping systems or parts of systems are completely manufactured and equipped with all fittings, the test may be conducted prior to installation on board the ship. Joints welded on board shall be tested to at least 1,5 times the design pressure.

LR 16.7-06 After assembly on board, the fuel piping system shall be subjected to a leak test using air, or another suitable medium to a pressure depending on the leak detection method applied.

16.7.3.6 Emergency shutdown valves in liquefied gas piping systems shall close fully and smoothly within 30 s of actuation. Information about the closure time of the valves and their operating characteristics shall be available on board, and the closing time shall be verifiable and repeatable.

16.7.3.7 The closing time of the valve referred to in 8.5.8 and 15.4.2.2 (i.e. time from shutdown signal initiation to complete valve closure) shall not be greater than:

  • where:
  • U = ullage volume at operating signal level (m3);
  • BR = maximum bunkering rate agreed between ship and shore facility (m3/h); or
  • 5 seconds, whichever is the least.

The bunkering rate shall be adjusted to limit surge pressure on valve closure to an acceptable level, taking into account the bunkering hose or arm, the ship and the shore piping systems, where relevant.


Copyright 2022 Clasifications Register Group Limited, International Maritime Organization, International Labour Organization or Maritime and Coastguard Agency. All rights reserved. Clasifications Register Group Limited, its affiliates and subsidiaries and their respective officers, employees or agents are, individually and collectively, referred to in this clause as 'Clasifications Register'. Clasifications Register assumes no responsibility and shall not be liable to any person for any loss, damage or expense caused by reliance on the information or advice in this document or howsoever provided, unless that person has signed a contract with the relevant Clasifications Register entity for the provision of this information or advice and in that case any responsibility or liability is exclusively on the terms and conditions set out in that contract.