4 Strength criteria
Clasification Society 2024 - Version 9.40
Statutory Documents - IMO Publications and Documents - International Conferences - SOLAS/CONF.4 - Resolutions of the Conference of Contracting Governments to the International Convention for the Safety of Life at Sea, 1974 – (November 1997) - Resolution 4 - Standards for the evaluation of scantlings and for the evaluation of allowable hold loading of the foremost cargo hold – (Adopted on 27 November 1997) - Annex 1 - Standards for the evaluation of scantlings of the transverse watertight vertically corrugated bulkhead between the two foremost cargo holds - 4 Strength criteria

4 Strength criteria

4.1 General

 The following criteria are applicable to transverse bulkheads with vertical corrugations (see figure 2a).

Requirements for local net plate thickness are given in 4.7

In addition, the criteria given in 4.2 and 4.5 are to be complied with.

Where the corrugation angle 4 shown in figure 2a is less than 50°, a horizontal row of staggered shedder plates is to be fitted at approximately mid-depth of the corrugations (see figure 2a) to help preserve dimensional stability of the bulkhead under flooding loads. The shedder plates are to be welded to the corrugations by double continuous welding, but they are not to be welded to the side shell.

The thicknesses of the lower part of corrugations considered in the application of 4.2 and 4.3 are to be maintained for a distance from the inner bottom (if no lower stool is fitted) or the top of the lower stool not less than 0.15.ℓ.

The thicknesses of the middle part of corrugations considered in the application of 4.2 and 4.4 are to be maintained to a distance from the deck (if no upper stool is fitted) or the bottom of the upper stool not greater than 0.3.ℓ.

4.2 Bending capacity and shear stress

 The bending capacity is to comply with the following relationship:

where:
M = bending moment, in kN.m, as given in 3.1
Z le = section modulus of one half pitch corrugation, in cm3, at the lower end of corrugations, to be calculated according to 4.3
Z m = section modulus of one half pitch corrugation, in cm3, at the mid-span of corrugations, to be calculated according to 4.4
σ a,le = allowable stress, in FT/mm2, as given in 4.5, for the lower end of corrugations
σ a,m = allowable stress, in N/ mm2 , as given in 4.5, for the mid-span of corrugations.

In no case is Z m to be taken greater than the lesser of 1.15.Z le, and 1.15.Z'le for calculation of the bending capacity, Z'le being defined below.

In case effective shedder plates are fitted which:

  • are not knuckled;
  • are welded to the corrugations and the top of the lower stool by one side penetration weld or equivalent;
  • are fitted with a minimum slope of 45° and their lower edge is in line with the stool side plating;

or effective gusset plates are fitted which:

  • are fitted in line with the stool side plating;
  • have material properties at least equal to those provided for the flanges,

the section modulus Z le, in cm3, is to be taken not larger than the value Z'le, in cm3, given by:

where:
Z g = section modulus of one half pitch corrugation, in cm3, according to 4.4, in way of the upper end of shedder or gusset plates, as applicable
Q = shear force, in kN, as given in 3.2
h g = height, in m, of shedders or gusset plates, as applicable (see figures 3a, 3b, 4a and 4b)
s 1 = as given in 2.3.1 (a)
p g = resultant pressure, in kN/m2, as defined in 2.5, calculated in way of the middle of the shedders or gusset plates, as applicable
δ a = allowable stress, in N/mm2, as given in 4.5.

Shear stresses τ are obtained by dividing the shear force Q by the shear area. The shear area is to be reduced in order to account for possible non-perpendicularity between the corrugation webs and flanges. In general, the reduced shear area may be obtained by multiplying the web sectional area by (sin θ), θ being the angle between the web and the flange.

When calculating the section moduli and the shear area, the net plate thicknesses are to be used.

The section moduli of corrugations are to be calculated on the basis of the requirements standards given in 4.3 and 4.4.

Figure 3a Symmetric shedder plates

Figure 3b Asymmetric shedder plates

Figure 4a Symmetric gusset/shedder plates

Figure 4b Asmmetric gusset/shedder plates

Figure 5

4.3 Section modulus at the lower end of corrugations

 The section modulus is to be calculated with the compression flange having an effective flange width, b cf, not larger than as given in 4.6.1.

If the corrugation webs are not supported by local brackets below the stool top (or below the inner bottom) in the lower part, the section modulus of the corrugations is to be calculated considering the corrugation webs 30%) effective.

  • (a) Provided that effective shedder plates, as defined in 4.2, are fitted (see figures 3a and 3b), when calculating the section modulus of corrugations at the lower end (cross-section (1) in figures 3a and 3b), the area of flange plates, in cm2, may be increased by:

    where:
    a = width, in m, of the corrugation flange (see figure 2a)
    t sh = net shedder plate thickness, in mm
    t f = net flange thickness, in mm
    σ Fsh = minimum upper yield stress, in N/mm2, of the material used for the shedder plates
    σ Ffl = minimum upper yield stress, in N/mm2, of the material used for the corrugation flanges.
  • (b) Provided that effective gusset plates, as defined in 4.2, are fitted (see figures 4a and 4b), when calculating the section modulus of corrugations at the lower end (cross-section (1) in figures 4a and 4b), the area of flange plates, in cm2, may be increased by (7.h g.t gu)

    where:
    h g = height of gusset plate, in m (see figures 4a and 4b), not to be taken greater than (.s gu)
    s gu = width of the gusset plates, in m
    t gu = net gusset plate thickness, in mm, not to be taken greater than t f
    t f = net flange thickness, in mm, based on the as-built condition.
  • (c) If the corrugation webs are welded to a sloping stool top plate which is at an angle not less than 45° with the horizontal plane, the section modulus of the corrugations may be calculated considering the corrugation webs fully effective. In case effective gusset plates are fitted, when calculating the section modulus of corrugations the area of flange plates may be increased as specified in (b) above. No credit can be given to shedder plates only.

    For angles less than 45°, the effectiveness of the web may be obtained by linear interpolation between 30% for 0° and 100% for 45°.

4.4 Section modulus of corrugations at cross-sections other than the lower end

 The section modulus is to be calculated with 'the corrugation webs considered effective and the compression flange having an effective flange width, b cf, not larger than as given in 4.6.1.

4.5 Allowable stress check

 The normal and shear stresses σ and τ are not to exceed the allowable values σ a and τ a, in N/mm2, given by:

where:
σ F = the minimum upper yield stress, in N/mm2, of the material.

4.6 Effective compression flange width and shear buckling check

4.6.1 Effective width of the compression flange of corrugations

 The effective width b cf, in m, of the corrugation flange is given by:

where:
C e =
C e =
β =
t f = net flange thickness, in mm
a = width, in m, of the corrugation flange (see figure 2a)
σ F = minimum upper yield stress, in N/mm2, of the material
E = modulus of elasticity, in N/mm2, to be assumed equal to 2.06 × 105 N/mm2 for steel.

4.6.2 Shear

 The buckling check is to be performed for the web plates at the corrugation ends.

The shear stress τ is not to exceed the critical value τ c, in N/mm2, as obtained from the following:

where:
τ F =
σ F = minimum upper yield stress, in N/mm2, of the material as given in 4.6.1
τ E =
= k t, E, t and c are given by:
k t = 6.34
E = modulus of elasticity of material as given in 4.6.1
t = net thickness, in mm, of corrugation web
c = width, in m, of corrugation web (see figure 2a).

4.7 Local net plate thickness

 The bulkhead local net plate thickness t, in mm, is given by:

where:
s w = plate width, in m, to be taken equal to the width of the corrugation flange or web, whichever is the greater (see figure 2a)
p = resultant pressure, in kN/m2, as defined in 2.5, at the bottom of each strake of plating; in all cases, the net thickness of the lowest strake is to be determined using the resultant pressure at the top of the lower stool, or at the inner bottom, if no lower stool is fitted or at the top of shedders, if shedder or gusset/shedder plates are fitted.
σ F = minimum upper yield stress, in N/mm2, of the material.

For built-up corrugated bulkheads, when the thicknesses of the flange and web are different, the net thickness of the narrower plating is to be not less than t n, in mm, given by:

where:
s n = the width, in m, of the narrower plating.

The net thickness of the wider plating, in mm, is not to be taken less than the maximum of the following values:

and

where:
t np = actual net thickness of the narrower plating and not to be greater than

Copyright 2022 Clasifications Register Group Limited, International Maritime Organization, International Labour Organization or Maritime and Coastguard Agency. All rights reserved. Clasifications Register Group Limited, its affiliates and subsidiaries and their respective officers, employees or agents are, individually and collectively, referred to in this clause as 'Clasifications Register'. Clasifications Register assumes no responsibility and shall not be liable to any person for any loss, damage or expense caused by reliance on the information or advice in this document or howsoever provided, unless that person has signed a contract with the relevant Clasifications Register entity for the provision of this information or advice and in that case any responsibility or liability is exclusively on the terms and conditions set out in that contract.