Section 3 Design load combinations
Clasification Society 2024 - Version 9.40
Clasifications Register Rules and Regulations - Rules and Regulations for the Classification of Naval Ships, January 2023 - Volume 1 Ship Structures - Part 7 Enhanced Structural Assessment (Provisional) - Chapter 2 Total Design Loads - Section 3 Design load combinations

Section 3 Design load combinations

3.1 General

3.1.1 The local and global loads given in Vol 1, Pt 5, Ch 3 Local Design Loads and Vol 1, Pt 5, Ch 4 Global Design Loads do not include any allowance for phase relationships between the various loadings. These loads are not all maximum at the same time and consequently it is not correct to apply all loads simultaneously to the structure. The purpose of this section is to define the phase relationships and hence allow typical maximum load combinations to be applied to the structure.

3.1.2 Special load case combinations may be required to reflect specific operational requirements of the vessel, e.g. sea state 6 operation with the stern well dock flooded for amphibious operations. The details of such operational modes together with any service limitations are to be recorded in the design disclosure document and the Operations Manual, Loading Manual or Stability Information Book.

3.1.3 Proposals for deriving the load combinations using direct calculation techniques are to be agreed with LR at the earliest opportunity.

3.2 Design cases for load combinations

3.2.1 The load combinations given in Table 2.3.1 Design load combination factors are the minimum to be considered for the assessment of the scantlings. Additional load combination cases may be required to demonstrate that the structure is adequate.

3.2.2 Each set of load combinations may need to be considered for individual loading conditions to account for differences in local loadings, e.g. different tank fillings, payload or other loadings. This may be performed using either:

  1. an envelope approach with due consideration of full/ empty tanks, etc. or

  2. individual load combination sets, in which case the actual still water bending moment and shear force distributions may be used together with the actual draught, trim and deadweight distribution.

For example, it will be necessary to consider two design cases to review the double bottom tanks, i.e. one with the double bottom tank full and one with the double bottom tank empty.

3.2.3 Load combination cases 1 to 4 are based on the premise that the maximum wave bending moment and shear forces are likely to be generated on a wave that has the same length as the ship.

Table 2.3.1 Design load combination factors

Case No 1 2 3 4 5 6
Design factor Design Sag case Max pitch
bow up
Design Hog case Max pitch
bow down
Roll case Design factor affects the following loads
Crest at FP Trough at 0,5L R Crest at 0,75L R Trough at 0,25L R Crest at 0,5L R Trough at FP Crest at 0,25L R Trough at 0,75L R
w g
(global loads)
–1,0 +1,0 To be specially considered M W, M WRS,
Q W and Q WRS
see Vol 1, Pt 7, Ch 2, 3.3 Design global loads – Intact conditions and Vol 1, Pt 7, Ch 2, 3.4 Design global loads – Damaged conditions or Residual Strength Assessment (RSA) conditions
w p
(external pressure loads)
+ cos (2πx/L R) –sin (2πx/L R) + cos (2πx/L R) –sin (2πx/L R) To be specially considered P SS, Vol 1, Pt 7, Ch 2, 3.6 External shell pressures
LT
QT
w f
(inertial loads)
Combined heave and pitch design factor based on w fheave and w fpitch, see Vol 1, Pt 7, Ch 2, 3.5 Inertial force load combination factor, wf P CD, F CD
LV, L A
w fheave
(heave inertial)
+1 0 –1 0 To be specially considered  
w fpitch
(pitch inertial)
0 +1 0 –1 To be specially considered  

Note 2. The factor w p is to be applied to the dynamic portion of the load component, see Vol 1, Pt 7, Ch 2, 3.6 External shell pressures.

Note 3. The factor w f is to be applied to the dynamic portion of the load component, see Vol 1, Pt 7, Ch 2, 3.5 Inertial force load combination factor, wf. The w fheave and w fpitch factors are required to consider the phasing between heave and pitch accelerations.

Note 4. x is the longitudinal location under consideration.

Note 5. Sin and cos are the sine and cosine functions with the angle in radians.

3.2.4 Each load case combination consists of a set of w factors, some of these combination factors are longitudinally position dependent factors, e.g. the w p term will produce maximum pressure amidships and low pressures at the ends for the maximum hogging BM case.

3.3 Design global loads – Intact conditions

3.3.1 The design global hull girder vertical bending moment to be associated with the design load combination cases is as follows:

M D = M S + |w g| M W kNm

where

|w g| = absolute value of w g

M S and M W are the sagging or hogging values of M S and M W at the longitudinal position under consideration. If w g is positive then the hogging values of M S and M W are to be taken, otherwise w g is negative and the sagging values of M S and M W are to be taken.

M S and M W are given in Vol 1, Pt 5, Ch 4, 2.2 Still water bending moments and Vol 1, Pt 7, Ch 2, 3.3 Design global loads – Intact conditions

w g is given in Table 2.3.1 Design load combination factors.

3.3.2 The design global hull girder vertical shear force to be associated with the design load combination cases is as follows:

Q D = Q S + |w g| Q W kN

where

|w g| = absolute value of w g

Q S and Q W are the sagging or hogging values of Q S and Q W at the longitudinal position under consideration. If w g is positive then the hogging values of Q S and Q WH are to be taken, otherwise w g is negative and the sagging values of Q S and Q WS are to be taken.

Q S is given in Vol 1, Pt 5, Ch 4, 2.3 Still water shear forces

Q WS and Q WH are given in Vol 1, Pt 7, Ch 2, 3.7 Vertical wave shear forces

w g is given in Table 2.3.1 Design load combination factors

3.4 Design global loads – Damaged conditions or Residual Strength Assessment (RSA) conditions

3.4.1 The design global hull girder vertical bending moments to be associated with the design load combination cases for residual strength assessment or damaged conditions is to be taken as follows:

M D = M SRS + |w g| M WRS kNm

where.

|w g| = absolute value of w g

M SRS and M WRS are the sagging or hogging values of M SRS and M WRS at the longitudinal position under consideration. If w g is positive then the hogging values of M SRS and M WRS are to be taken, otherwise w g is negative and the sagging values of M SRS and M WRS are to be taken.

M SRS and M WRS are given in Vol 1, Pt 5, Ch 4, 5.6 Damaged still water shear forces and bending moments

w g is given in Table 2.3.1 Design load combination factors

3.4.2 The design global hull girder vertical shear force to be associated with the design load combination cases for residual strength assessment or damaged conditions is to be taken as follows:

Q D = Q SRS + |w g| Q WRS kN

where

|w g| = absolute value of w g

Q SRS and Q WRS are the sagging or hogging values of Q SRS and Q WRS at the longitudinal position under consideration. If w g is positive then the hogging values of Q SRS and Q WRS,H are to be taken, otherwise w g is negative and the sagging values of Q SRS and Q WRS,S are to be taken.

Q SRS is given in Vol 1, Pt 5, Ch 4, 5.6 Damaged still water shear forces and bending moments and Vol 1, Pt 5, Ch 4, 5.4 Residual strength vertical wave shear forces

w g is given in Table 2.3.1 Design load combination factors

Q WRS,S and Q WRS,H are given in Vol 1, Pt 7, Ch 2, 3.7 Vertical wave shear forces 3.7.2

3.5 Inertial force load combination factor, w f

3.5.1 The inertial force load combination factor, w f, to be associated with the design load combination cases is as follows:

w f = (1 + a z)

where

a z = w fheave a heave + w fpitch a pitch

w fheave and w fpitch are to be taken for the appropriate loading condition, see Table 2.3.1 Design load combination factors

a heave and a pitch are defined in Table 3.2.1 Ship motions

3.6 External shell pressures

3.6.1 The side shell pressure, P SS, to be applied to all external plating is to be derived as follows:

P SS = P h + w p P w kN/m2

but

  • P SS ≥ 0

w p is defined in Table 2.3.1 Design load combination factors

P h and P w are defined in Vol 1, Pt 5, Ch 3, 3.2 Combined hydrostatic and hydrodynamic pressure on the shell plating, Ps and Vol 1, Pt 5, Ch 3, 3.3 Hydrostatic pressure on the shell plating, Ph.

3.6.2 The weather deck pressure, P WD, to be applied to all external plating is to be derived as follows:

P WD = P h + w p P wd kN/m2

but

P WD ≥ 0

w p is defined in Table 2.3.1 Design load combination factors

P wd is defined in Vol 1, Pt 5, Ch 3, 3.5 Pressure on exposed and weather decks, Pwd

3.7 Vertical wave shear forces

3.7.1 The wave shear force curves associated with the hogging and sagging bending moments required by the total load approach are to be taken as follows:

Q WH = shear force distribution to give the hogging bending moment
= 3K b M o/L R kN

where

K b is to be taken as follows:

K b = 0 at aft end of L R
= +0,836F fH between 0,2L R and 0,3L R
= +0,65F fH between 0,4L R and 0,5L R
= –0,65F fH between 0,5L R and 0,6L R
= –0,91F fH between 0,7L R and 0,85L R
= 0 at forward end of L R
Q WS = shear force distribution to give the sagging bending moment
= 3K b M o/L R kN

where

K b is to be taken as follows:

K b = 0 at aft end of LR
= +0,836F fS between 0,15L R and 0,3L R
= +0,65F fS between 0,4L Rand 0,5L R
= +0,65F fS between 0,5L R and 0,6LR
= –0,91F fS between 0,7L R and 0,85L R
= 0 at forward end of L R

Intermediate values are to be determined by linear interpolation.

M o, F fH and F fS are given in Vol 1, Pt 5, Ch 4, 3.3 Vertical wave bending moments

3.7.2 The wave shear force associated with the residual strength assessment load cases or damaged load cases is to be taken as follows:

QWRS,H = shear force distribution to give the hogging bending moment
= K fRS Q WH

where

Q WRS,S = shear force distribution to give the sagging bending moment
= K fRS Q WS

where


Copyright 2022 Clasifications Register Group Limited, International Maritime Organization, International Labour Organization or Maritime and Coastguard Agency. All rights reserved. Clasifications Register Group Limited, its affiliates and subsidiaries and their respective officers, employees or agents are, individually and collectively, referred to in this clause as 'Clasifications Register'. Clasifications Register assumes no responsibility and shall not be liable to any person for any loss, damage or expense caused by reliance on the information or advice in this document or howsoever provided, unless that person has signed a contract with the relevant Clasifications Register entity for the provision of this information or advice and in that case any responsibility or liability is exclusively on the terms and conditions set out in that contract.