Section 8 Determination of forces for container securing arrangements
Clasification Society 2024 - Version 9.40
Clasifications Register Rules and Regulations - Rules and Regulations for the Classification of Ships, July 2022 - Part 3 Ship Structures (General) - Chapter 14 Cargo Securing Arrangements - Section 8 Determination of forces for container securing arrangements

Section 8 Determination of forces for container securing arrangements

8.1 General

8.1.1 The forces acting in the securing system are to be determined for each loading condition and associated set of motions of the ship.

8.1.2 The following forces are to be taken into account:

  • Static gravity forces.
  • Inertial forces generated by the ship motions in a seaway.
  • Wind forces.
  • Forces imposed by the securing arrangements.
  • Wave impact forces and effects of consequential hull girder whipping.

8.1.3 Forces due to pre-tensioning the securing devices need not, in general, be included in the calculation, provided that they do not exceed 5 kN in any one item. Special consideration will be given to cases where forces obtained from pre-stressing are an integral part of the design of the system.

8.1.4 Although the operation of anti-roll devices or other systems may improve the behaviour of the ship in a seaway, the effect of such devices is not normally to be taken into account to reduce the determination of the forces for container securing arrangements. Where the reliability of such systems can be demonstrated, special consideration of the roll motions will be given. Supporting documentation to demonstrate the effectiveness of an anti-rolling system should identify the redundancy incorporated in the control system and details of actual measurements from the ship over a period of time, including route and season of operation.

8.2 Ship motion, wind and green sea forces acting on containers

8.2.1 The forces acting on each container due to gravity, ship motion accelerations, ship rolling and pitching angles and wind forces and green sea forces are to be calculated as follows.

8.2.2  The equations for ship motion accelerations and other motion parameters are given in Pt 3, Ch 14, 1.7 Symbols and definitions. These are to be used for the calculation of accelerations to derive the forces for the container securing arrangements. Alternatively, the ship motion values may be derived by direct calculation methods using the same principles as those used to derive the Rule equations. The formulae in Pt 3, Ch 14, 1.7 Symbols and definitions are applicable to container ships. Values for other ship types will be specially considered.

8.2.3 The following six Motion Cases (MCs) are to be considered:

  MC1: Head sea case that maximises vertical acceleration
  MC2: Beam sea case that maximises roll motion
  MC3: Oblique sea case that maximises pitch acceleration
  MC4: Oblique sea case with forward speed that maximises roll motion
  MC5: Oblique sea case that maximises combined transverse and vertical accelerations
  MC6: Beam sea case that maximises heave acceleration

Each Motion Case comprises 2 Motion Combination Factor (MCF) sets. Each MCF set represents an Equivalent Design Wave (EDW) that generates response values equivalent to the long-term response values of the critical load components for ship motion forces acting on containers. The Motion Combination Factors are given in Table 14.8.3 Motion Combination Factors (MCFs).

8.2.4 The individual force components for each Motion Case due to gravity, ship motions, wind and green seas acting on a container i are to be determined as follows, see Figure 14.1.1 Diagrammatic representation of symbols and Table 14.9.1 Acceleration force application:

H Di = force acting on container i in kN in transverse direction parallel to deck, positive to port
= W a y
J Di = force acting on container i in kN in longitudinal direction parallel to deck, positive forward
= W a x
P Di = force acting on container i in kN in vertical direction normal to deck, positive upward
= W a z
Q Di = wind force acting on exposed container i in kN in transverse direction parallel to deck, positive to port
= Q DSi Q DMi
where:
QDMi = wind force magnitude acting on exposed container i in kN in transverse direction parallel to deck
=

where:

Croll wind force coefficient to include effect of roll angle
=
ρa density of air in kg/m3 is to be taken as
= 1,204
CZ wind force height distribution coefficient
=
Vwh mean wind speed over the stack in m/s
=

ztc height above moulded draught, Tc, of the top of the highest container in the stack under consideration, in m

zbc height above moulded draught, Tc, of the underside of the stack under consideration, in m

zci height above moulded draught, Tc, of the centre of the side wall of container i, in m

Cwh wind heading coefficient, given in Table 14.8.1 Wind heading coefficient C wh

CyG transverse acceleration motion combination factor CyG, given in Table 14.8.3 Motion Combination Factors (MCFs)

Other symbols are defined in Pt 3, Ch 14, 1.7 Symbols and definitions.

QDSi = Wind force direction coefficient
= -1 if HDi ≤ 0 kN
= 1 if HDi > 0 kN
H Gi = green sea force acting on container i, in kN in transverse direction parallel to deck, positive to port
= b c i P gs for port side exposed containers
= b c i P gs for starboard side exposed containers
Note 1. HGi is only to be applied when HGi will increase the transverse force HDi.
J Gi = green sea force acting on container i, in kN in longitudinal direction parallel to deck, positive forward
= a c i P gs
Note 1. JGi is only to be applied when JGi will increase the longitudinal force JDi.
P Gi = green sea force acting on container i, in kN in the upwards direction normal to deck
= 1,5a b
Note 1. PGi is only to be applied when the vertical acceleration az > -9,81 m/s2 (downward acceleration less than gravitational acceleration).

where

Table 14.8.1 Wind heading coefficient C wh

  Wind heading coefficient C wh
Motion case
see Note 1
Only applied to the
exposed side walls of containers as defined in Pt 3, Ch 14, 8.2 Ship motion, wind and green sea forces acting on containers 8.2.7 and Pt 3, Ch 14, 8.2 Ship motion, wind and green sea forces acting on containers 8.2.8
MC1, see Note 2 0
MC2 1,00
MC3 0,866
MC4 0,866
MC5 0,866
MC6 1,00

Note 2. No wind loads are to be applied to Motion Case MC1.

8.2.5 The total instantaneous acceleration values acting on container i, including the static gravitational term, are to be taken as:

  • Longitudinal acceleration (parallel to deck, positive forward)

    a x = C xS a surge + C xP a pitch z ig sin (C xG ψ) m/s2

  • Transverse acceleration (parallel to deck, positive to port)
    1. For containers on the port side and on the centreline:

      a y = C yS a swayC yR a roll z i + g sin (C yG φ) m/s2

    2. For containers on the starboard side:

      a y = –C yS a sway + C yR a roll z ig sin (C yG φ) m/s2


  • Vertical acceleration (normal to deck, positive upwards)
    1. For containers on the port side and on the centreline:

      a z = C p1 (C zH a heave + C zR a roll y if ap C zP a pitch x i ) – g cos (C xG ψ) cos (C yG φ) m/s2

    2. For containers on the starboard side

      a z = C p1 (C zH a heave C zR a roll y if ap C zP a pitch x i ) – g cos (C xG ψ) cos (C yG φ) m/s2


where the Motion Combination Factors C xS, C xP, C xG, C yS, C yR, C yG, C zH, C zR and C zP for each Motion Case are given in Table 14.8.3 Motion Combination Factors (MCFs).

8.2.6 Wind forces are to be applied to the outer faces of the outermost container stack in accordance with Pt 3, Ch 14, 8.2 Ship motion, wind and green sea forces acting on containers 8.2.4. Wind forces may also need to be applied to inboard stacks in accordance with Pt 3, Ch 14, 8.2 Ship motion, wind and green sea forces acting on containers 8.2.7. The wind forces are to be taken as acting in the athwartships direction. Only positive forces of wind pressure are to be applied; suction forces need not be included. See Figure 14.8.1 Application of wind forces

8.2.7 Wind forces are to be applied to containers in inboard stacks if the centre of the windward side wall of the container is above the wind shear line, see Figure 14.8.1 Application of wind forces. The wind shear line is to be taken at an angle of 35 degrees to the horizontal and passing through upper deck at side, the upper outer edge of the hatch cover or the top corner of the uppermost container of any windward stack, as applicable, see Figure 14.8.1 Application of wind forces. The roll angle is to be ignored in the assessment of the wind shear line. The wind force is to be derived in accordance with Pt 3, Ch 14, 8.2 Ship motion, wind and green sea forces acting on containers 8.2.4 but see also Pt 3, Ch 14, 8.2 Ship motion, wind and green sea forces acting on containers 8.2.8.
  • Hence wind forces are to be applied to containers in inboard stacks if:
  • Where:
  • zci is the vertical position of the centre of the windward side wall of container i of the stack under consideration
  • yws is the transverse position of the windward upper deck at side, the upper outer edge of the hatch cover or the top corner of the uppermost container of the stacks windward of the stack under consideration as applicable
  • zws is the vertical position of the windward upper deck at side, the upper outer edge of the hatch cover or the top corner of the uppermost container of the stacks windward of the stack under consideration as applicable
  • yci is the transverse position of the centre of the windward side wall of container i of the stack under consideration


Note Note. The formula in Pt 3, Ch 14, 8.2 Ship motion, wind and green sea forces acting on containers 8.2.7 compares points at the container base and centre. The drawing compares points at the side. Both comparisons yield the same result.

Figure 14.8.1 Application of wind forces

Figure 14.8.2 Example of application of green sea forces

8.2.8 A container is considered protected from wind in the transverse direction or from green sea loads in the longitudinal or transverse direction if an effective breakwater or similar extends above mid height of the container.

8.2.9 A container is considered partially protected from wind if an outboard container partially shields an inboard container as follows:
  • An outboard 40ft container is considered to fully protect a longer inboard container.
  • An outboard 20ft container is considered to partially protect a longer inboard container from wind. In this case the full wind force is to be applied over the exposed portion of the longer inboard container when the exposed length is more than 3m. The resulting wind force is to be applied solely to the end wall of the exposed portion.
8.2.10 A container is considered protected from green sea loads in the vertical direction if:
  • the underside is less than 0,5 m above the hatch cover or deck; or
  • an effective breakwater or similar extends above the bottom of the container.
8.2.11 Green sea loads need only be applied to a container when (see Pt 3, Ch 14, 8.2 Ship motion, wind and green sea forces acting on containers 8.2.7):
Note In general, Tier 1 position corresponds to lowest tier of containers sitting just above the deck and Tier 2 position corresponds to the lowest tier of containers sitting just above the hatch covers, see Pt 3, Ch 14, 8.2 Ship motion, wind and green sea forces acting on containers 8.2.7.

8.2.12 The green sea pressure is given by:

for L >100

P gs = C G1 L 2 + C G2 L + C G3 kN/m2 but not less than 0

for L ≤ 100, P gs is to be taken as:

= 1,5 for Tier 1
= 1,0 for Tier 2
= 0,5 for Tier 3

where

C G1, C G2, C G3 are defined in Table 14.8.2 Green sea pressure coefficients
Proposals to use other values for green sea forces will be specially considered

Table 14.8.2 Green sea pressure coefficients

  C G1 C G2 C G3
Tier 1 –0,000017 0,0035 1,32
Tier 2 –0,000020 0,0040 0,80
Tier 3 –0,000023 0,0045 0,28

Table 14.8.3 Motion Combination Factors (MCFs)

      Longitudinal acceleration Transverse acceleration Vertical acceleration
Motion
Case
Heading MCF a-surge a-pitch g*sin ψ a-sway a-roll g*sin φ a-heave a-roll a-pitch
      C xS C xP C xG C yS C yR C yG C zH C zR C zP
MC1 Head HS_1 –0,69 1,00 –0,85 0,00 0,00 0,00 –0,18 0,00 1,00
HS_2 0,69 –1,00 0,85 0,00 0,00 0,00 0,18 0,00 –1,00
MC2 Beam BS1_1 0,00 0,00 0,00 –0,09 0,66 –0,66 0,14 0,66 0,00
BS1_2 0,00 0,00 0,00 0,09 –0,66 0,66 –0,14 –0,66 0,00
MC3 Oblique OS1_1 –0,43 1,00 –0,86 –0,28 –0,22 0,05 –0,29 –0,22 1,00
OS1_2 0,43 –1,00 0,86 0,28 0,22 –0,05 0,29 0,22 –1,00
MC4 Oblique OS2_1 0,00 0,00 0,00 –0,02 1,00 –1,00 0,00 1,00 0,00
OS2_2 0,00 0,00 0,00 0,02 –1,00 1,00 0,00 –1,00 0,00
MC5 Oblique OS3_1 0,62 –0,46 0,65 0,96 –0,36 0,12 0,11 –0,36 –0,46
OS3_2 –0,62 0,46 –0,65 –0,96 0,36 –0,12 –0,11 0,36 0,46
MC6 Beam BS2_1 –0,07 –0,05 0,02 0,62 0,12 –0,01 1,00 0,12 –0,05
BS2_2 0,07 0,05 –0,02 –0,62 –0,12 0,01 –1,00 –0,12 0,05

Copyright 2022 Clasifications Register Group Limited, International Maritime Organization, International Labour Organization or Maritime and Coastguard Agency. All rights reserved. Clasifications Register Group Limited, its affiliates and subsidiaries and their respective officers, employees or agents are, individually and collectively, referred to in this clause as 'Clasifications Register'. Clasifications Register assumes no responsibility and shall not be liable to any person for any loss, damage or expense caused by reliance on the information or advice in this document or howsoever provided, unless that person has signed a contract with the relevant Clasifications Register entity for the provision of this information or advice and in that case any responsibility or liability is exclusively on the terms and conditions set out in that contract.