Section 4 Buckling control
Clasification Society 2024 - Version 9.40
Clasifications Register Rules and Regulations - Rules and Regulations for the Classification of Special Service Craft, July 2022 - Part 7 Hull Construction in Aluminium - Chapter 7 Failure Modes Control - Section 4 Buckling control

Section 4 Buckling control

4.1 General

4.1.1 This Section contains the requirements for buckling control of plate panels subject to in-plane compressive and/or shear stresses and buckling control of primary and secondary stiffening members subject to axial compressive and shear stresses.

4.1.3 In general all areas of the structure are to meet the buckling strength requirements for the design stresses. The design stresses are to be taken as follows:

  1. Global hull girder bending and shear stresses given in Chapter 6, but not including stresses σl and σt as defined in Table 6.2.1 Longitudinal component stresses in Pt 7, Ch 6 Hull Girder Strength.

  2. Stresses from local compressive loads.

4.1.4 The buckling requirements are to be met using the net scantlings, hence any additional thickness for corrosion margin or Owners' extra is not included in scantlings used to assess the buckling performance.

4.2 Symbols

4.2.1 The symbols used in this Section are defined below and in the appropriate sub-Section:

t p = thickness of plating, in mm
A R = panel aspect ratio
=
a = panel length, i.e. parallel to direction of compressive stress being considered, in mm
b = panel breadth, i.e. perpendicular to direction of compressive stress being considered, in mm
S p = span of primary members, in metres
σa = 0,2 per cent proof stress of the material, in N/mm2
σe = elastic compressive buckling stress, in N/mm2
σc = critical compressive buckling stress, including the effects of plasticity where appropriate, in N/mm2
τa = specified minimum yield shear stress the of material, in N/mm2
=
E = modulus of elasticity of material, in N/mm2
τe = elastic shear buckling stress, in N/mm2
τc = critical shear buckling stress, in N/mm2
b eb = lesser of 1,9t p or 0,8b mm
A te = cross-sectional area of secondary stiffener, in cm2, including an effective breadth of attached plating, b eb
s = length of shorter edge of plate panel, in mm (typically the spacing of secondary stiffeners)
= length of longer edge of plate panel, in metres
S = spacing of primary member, in metres (measured in direction of compression)

4.3 Plate panel buckling requirements

4.3.1 This Section gives methods for evaluating the buckling strength of plate panels subjected to the following load fields:

  1. uni-axial compressive loads;

  2. shear loads;

  3. bi-axial compressive loads;

  4. uni-axial compressive loads and shear loads;

  5. bi-axial compressive loads and shear loads.

4.3.2 The plate panel buckling requirements will be satisfied if the buckling interaction equations given in Table 7.4.2 Plate panel buckling requirements for the above load fields are complied with.

4.3.3 The critical compressive buckling stresses and critical shear buckling stresses required for Table 7.4.2 Plate panel buckling requirements are to be derived in accordance with Pt 7, Ch 4, 4.4 Bottom outboard transverse stiffeners.

4.3.4 The buckling factors of safety λs and λt required by Table 7.4.2 Plate panel buckling requirements are given in Table 7.4.4 Buckling factor of safety for the structural member concerned.

4.3.5 For all structural members which contribute to the hull girder strength, the plate panel buckling requirements for uni-axial compressive loads, Table 7.4.2 Plate panel buckling requirements, and shear loads, Table 7.4.2 Plate panel buckling requirements are to be complied with.

4.3.6 In addition to Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.3 Plate panel buckling requirements 4.3.5, structural members which are subjected to local compressive loads and/or shear loads are to be verified using the plate panel buckling requirements in Table 7.4.2 Plate panel buckling requirements.

4.3.7 However, where some members of the structure have been designed such that elastic buckling of the plate panel between the stiffeners is allowable, then the requirements of Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.5 Additional requirements for plate panels which buckle elastically must be applied to the buckling analysis of the stiffeners supporting the plating. In addition, panels which do not satisfy the panel buckling requirements must be indicated on the appropriate drawing and the effect of these panels not being effective in transmitting compressive loads taken into account for the hull girder strength calculation.

4.3.8 In general the plate panel buckling requirements for more complex load fields, see Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.3 Plate panel buckling requirements 4.3.1.(c), Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.3 Plate panel buckling requirements 4.3.1.(d), Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.3 Plate panel buckling requirements 4.3.1.(e), are to be complied with. Where this is not possible, due to elastic buckling of the panel, then the critical buckling stress, σc, may be based on the ultimate collapse strength of the plating, σu from Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.5 Additional requirements for plate panels which buckle elastically 4.5.4, instead of the elastic buckling stress, σe, derived in Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.3 Plate panel buckling requirements 4.3.5. In addition, the requirements of Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.5 Additional requirements for plate panels which buckle elastically are to be met for the supporting secondary stiffeners and primary members.

4.4 Derivation of the buckling stress for plate panels

4.4.1 The critical compressive buckling stress, σc, and elastic buckling stress, σe, for a plate panel subjected to uni-axial in-plane compressive loads are to be derived in accordance with Table 7.4.1 Buckling stress of plate panels.

4.4.2 The critical shear buckling stress, τc, for a plate panel subjected to pure in-plane shear load is to be derived in accordance with Table 7.4.1 Buckling stress of plate panels.

Table 7.4.1 Buckling stress of plate panels

Mode Elastic buckling stress, N/mm2, see Note  
(a) Uni-axial compression:

(i) Long narrow panels,

loaded on the narrow edge

(ii) Short broad panels,


loaded on the broad edge



A R ≥ 1



A R < 1

(b) Pure shear:

NOTE

u is to be the minimum dimension

Note The critical buckling stresses, in N/mm2, are to be derived from the elastic buckling stresses as follows:

σc = σe when σe <
= σa when σe

σc is defined in Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.2 Symbols 4.2.1
σa is defined in Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.2 Symbols 4.2.1
τc = τe when τe <
= τa when τe

τc is defined in Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.2 Symbols 4.2.1
τa is defined in Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.2 Symbols 4.2.1
Symbols and definitions
A R = panel aspect ratio, see Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.2 Symbols 4.2.1
σe = elastic compressive buckling stress, in N/mm2
τe = elastic shear buckling stress, in N/mm2
a and b are the panel dimensions in mm, see figures above
t p = thickness of plating, in mm
φ = stress distribution factor for linearly varying compressive stress across plate width
= 0,47 μ2 - 1,4 μ + 1,93 for μ ≥ 0
= 1 for constant stress
μ = where σd1 and σd2 are the smaller and larger average compressive stresses respectively
E = Young's Modulus of elasticity of material, in N/mm2
C = stiffener influence factor for panels with stiffeners perpendicular to compressive stress
= 1,3 when plating stiffened by floors or deep girders
= 1,21 when stiffeners are built up profiles or rolled angles
= 1,10 when stiffeners are bulb flats
= 1,05 when stiffeners are flat bars
σd and τd are the design compressive and design shear stresses in the direction illustrated in the figures. With linearly varying stress across the plate panel, σd is to be taken as σd2

Table 7.4.2 Plate panel buckling requirements

  Stress field Buckling Interaction formula  
(a) uni-axial compressive loads
(b) shear loads
(c) bi-axial compressive loads for A R = 1,0





for other aspect ratios, i.e. AR ≠ 1,0







when G is taken from Figure 7.4.2 Secondary stiffening perpendicular to direction of compression

(d) uni-axial compressive loads plus shear load

for A R > 1







for A R ≤ 1


(e) bi-axial compressive loads plus shear loads

Symbols
σd = design compressive stress, see Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.1 General 4.1.3
σc = critical compressive buckling stress, in N/mm2, for uniaxial compressive load acting independently, see Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.3 Plate panel buckling requirements 4.3.5
σdx = design compressive stress in x direction
σdy = design compressive stress in the y direction
σcx = critical compressive buckling stress in x direction, see Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.3 Plate panel buckling requirements 4.3.5
σcy = critical compressive buckling stress in y direction, see Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.3 Plate panel buckling requirements 4.3.5
λs = buckling factor of safety for compressive stresses, see Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.3 Plate panel buckling requirements 4.3.4
λt = buckling factor of safety for shear stresses, see Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.3 Plate panel buckling requirements 4.3.4
τd = design shear stress, in N/mm2
τc = critical shear buckling stress, in N/mm2, acting independently, see Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.3 Plate panel buckling requirements 4.3.5

4.4.3 For welded plate panels the critical compressive buckling stress is to be reduced to account for the presence of residual welding stresses. The critical buckling stress is to be taken as the minimum of:

σcr = σe – σr
where
σr = reduction in compressive buckling stress due to residual welding stresses
=
βRS = residual stress coefficient dependent on type of weld (average value of βRS to be taken as 3)
b, t p and σa = are defined in Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.2 Symbols 4.2.1

4.4.4 In general the effect of lateral loading on plate panels (for example hydrostatic pressure on bottom shell plating) may be neglected and the critical buckling stresses calculated considering the in-plane stresses only.

4.4.5 Unless indicated otherwise, the effect of initial deflection on the buckling strength of plate panels may be ignored.

4.5 Additional requirements for plate panels which buckle elastically

4.5.1 Elastic buckling of plate panels between stiffeners occurs when both the following conditions are satisfied:

  1. The design compressive stress, σd, is greater than the elastic buckling stress of the plating, σe,

    σd > σe

  2. The elastic buckling stress is less than half the yield stress

    σe

4.5.2 Elastic buckling of local plating between stiffeners, including girders or floors etc, may be allowed if all of the following conditions are satisfied:

  1. The critical buckling stress of the stiffeners in all buckling modes is greater than the axial stress in the stiffeners after redistribution of the load from the elastically buckled plating into the stiffeners, hence

  2. Maximum predicted loadings are used in the calculations.

  3. Functional requirements will allow a degree of plating deformation.

where
i = a, t, w or f depending on the mode of buckling.
λσ = is the buckling factor of safety
= 1,25.

Table 7.4.3 Buckling stress of secondary stiffeners

Mode Elastic buckling stress, N/mm2 Critical buckling stress, N/mm2
see Note
(a) Overall buckling (perpendicular to plane of plating without rotation of cross-section)
σc(a)
(b) Torsional buckling
σc(t)
(c) Web buckling (excluding flat bar stiffeners)
σc(w)
(d) Flange buckling
σc(f)
The critical buckling stresses are to be derived from the elastic buckling stresses as follows:
σc = σe when σe <
= σa when σe
Symbols
d w = web depth, in mm, (excluding flange thickness for rolled sections), see Figure 7.4.4 Dimensions of longitudinals
t w = web thickness, in mm
b f = flange width, in mm (including web thickness)
t f = flange thickness, in mm. For bulb plates, the mean thickness of the bulb may be used, see Figure 7.4.4 Dimensions of longitudinals
e = effective span length of secondary stiffener in metres
C f = end constraint factor
= 1 where both ends are pinned
= 2 where one end pinned and the other end fixed
= 4 where both ends are fixed
E = Young's Modulus of elasticity of the material, in N/mm2
a = moment of inertia, in cm4, of longitudinal, including attached plating of effective width b eb, see Note

t p and σa are given in Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.2 Symbols 4.2.1

A te and b eb are given in Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.2 Symbols 4.2.1

t = St Venant's moment of inertia, in cm4, of longitudinal (without attached plating)
= for flat bars
= for built up profiles, rolled angles and bulb plates
p = polar moment of inertia, in cm4, of profile about connection of stiffener to plating
= for flat bars
= for built up profiles, rolled angles and bulb plates
w = sectorial moment of inertia, in cm6, of profile and connection of stiffener to plating
= for flat bars
= for `Tee' profiles
= for `L' profiles, rolled angles and bulb plates
C = spring stiffness exerted by supporting plate panel
=
k p = 1-ηp, and is not to be taken as less than zero. For built up profiles, rolled angles and bulb plates, k p need not be taken less than 0,1
ηp =
σep = elastic critical buckling stress, in N/mm2, of the supporting plate derived from Table 7.4.1 Buckling stress of plate panels
  m is determined as follows: e.g. m = 2 for K = 25  
  K 0 to 4 4 to 36 36 to 144 144 to 400 400 to 900 900 to 1764 (m - 1)2 m 2 to m 2(m + 1)2  
  m 1 2 3 4 5 6 m  
K = 104

σd is the design stress, in N/mm2

all other symbols are as defined in Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.2 Symbols 4.2.1.

Note For stiffeners attached to plating which buckles elastically, see Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.5 Additional requirements for plate panels which buckle elastically, the effective width of plating is to be taken as b eu.

Table 7.4.4 Buckling factor of safety

Structural item Buckling factor of safety (2) Compressive stresses, λσ Buckling factor of safety (3) Shear stresses, λt
Bottom shell plating 1,0
Inner bottom plating 1,0
Deck plating 1,0
Side shell plating 1,0 1,1
Longitudinal bulkhead plating 1,0 1,1
Double bottom girders 1,0 1,1
Longitudinal girders 1,0 1,1
Superstructures/deckhouses (partially longitudinally effective) 1,0
Longitudinal secondary stiffeners 1,1(1)
Girder and floor web plating subject to local loads 1,1 1,2

Note 1. The buckling factor of safety for stiffeners attached to plating which is allowed to buckle in the elastic mode due to the applied loads is to be taken as 1,25, see also Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.5 Additional requirements for plate panels which buckle elastically.

Note 2. Buckling factor of safety to be applied to the compressive stress due to global longitudinal stresses.

Note 3. Buckling factor of safety to be applied to the shear stress.

4.5.3 The effective breadth of attached plating for stiffeners, girder or beams that is to be used for the determination of the critical buckling stress of the stiffeners attached to plating which buckles elastically is to be taken as follows:

b eu = mm
where
σu = ultimate buckling strength of plating as given in Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.5 Additional requirements for plate panels which buckle elastically 4.5.4
b eu = effective panel breadth perpendicular to direction of compressive stress being considered
b = is given in Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.2 Symbols 4.2.1.

4.5.4 The ultimate buckling strength of plating, σu, which buckles elastically, may be determined as follows:

  1. shortest edge loaded, i.e. A R ≥ 1:

  2. longest edge loaded, i.e. A R < 1:

where

A R and s are defined in Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.2 Symbols 4.2.1.

t p, E and σa are defined in Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.2 Symbols 4.2.1.

4.5.5 The axial stress in stiffeners attached to plating which is likely to buckle elastically is to be derived as follows:

σde = σd
where
σd = is the axial stress in the stiffener when the plating can be considered fully effective
A t = A s + cm2
A tb = A s + cm2
where
b and b eu = are given in Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.5 Additional requirements for plate panels which buckle elastically 4.5.3
t = is the plating thickness, in mm
A s = is the stiffener area in cm2.

4.6 Shear buckling of stiffened panels

4.6.1 The shear buckling capability of longitudinally stiffened panels between primary members is to satisfy the following condition:

where
τc = is derived from Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.6 Shear buckling of stiffened panels 4.6.3
τd = is the design shear stress
λτ = is given in Table 7.4.3 Buckling stress of secondary stiffeners.

4.6.2 The elastic shear buckling stress of longitudinally stiffened panels between primary members may be taken as:

τe = K s E for A R ≥ 1

where

K s = 4,5
N = number of subpanels
=
ω =
se = moment of inertia of a section, in cm4, consisting of the longitudinal stiffener and a plate flange of effective width s/2
r = 1 — 0,75

s, , E and S p are as defined in Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.2 Symbols 4.2.1, see also Figure 7.4.1 Shear buckling of stiffened panels.

Figure 7.4.1 Shear buckling of stiffened panels

4.6.3 The critical shear buckling stress, τc, may be determined from te, see Note in Table 7.4.1 Buckling stress of plate panels.

4.7 Secondary stiffening in direction of compression

4.7.1 The buckling performance of stiffeners will be considered satisfactory if the following conditions are satisfied:

where

σc(a), σc(t), σc(w) and σc(f) are the critical buckling stresses of the stiffener for each mode of failure, see Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.7 Secondary stiffening in direction of compression 4.7.2

σd is the design compressive stress, see also Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.5 Additional requirements for plate panels which buckle elastically and Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.1 General 4.1.3

λσ is the buckling factor of safety given in Table 7.4.4 Buckling factor of safety. The value of λσ to be chosen depends on the buckling assessment of the attached plating, see Table 7.4.4 Buckling factor of safety.

4.7.2 The critical buckling stresses for the overall, torsional, web and flange buckling modes of longitudinals and secondary stiffening members under axial compressive loads are to be determined in accordance with Table 7.4.3 Buckling stress of secondary stiffeners.

4.7.3 To prevent torsional buckling of secondary stiffeners from occurring before buckling of the plating, the critical torsional buckling stress, σc(t), is to be greater than the critical buckling stress of the attached plating as detailed in Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.4 Derivation of the buckling stress for plate panels 4.4.1

4.7.4 The critical buckling stresses of the stiffener web, σc(w), and flange, σc(f), are to be greater than the critical torsional buckling stress, hence:

  1. σc(w) > σc(t)

  2. σc(f) > σc(t)

4.7.5 To ensure that overall buckling of the stiffened panel cannot occur before local buckling of the secondary stiffener, the critical overall buckling stress σc(a), is to be greater than the critical torsional buckling stress, hence

σc(a) > σc(t)

4.8 Secondary stiffening perpendicular to direction of compression

4.8.1 Where a stiffened panel of plating is subjected to a compressive load perpendicular to the direction of the stiffeners, see Figure 7.4.2 Secondary stiffening perpendicular to direction of compression, e.g. a transversely stiffened panel subject to longitudinal compressive load, the requirements of this Section are to be applied.

Figure 7.4.2 Secondary stiffening perpendicular to direction of compression

Figure 7.4.3 Interaction limiting stress curves of G for plate panels subject to bi-axial compression, see Pt 6, Ch 7, 4.4 Derivation of the buckling stress for plate panels 4.4.2

Figure 7.4.4 Dimensions of longitudinals

4.8.2 The minimum area moment of inertia of each stiffener including attached plating of width, s, to ensure that overall panel buckling does not precede plate buckling is to be taken as:

= mm4
where
D =
к = A R 2Π2
A R = plate panel aspect ratio
=
Π =
N L = number of plate panels
N L - 1 = number of stiffeners
υ = 0,3

s, l and S are defined in Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.2 Symbols 4.2.1 and shown in Figure 7.4.2 Secondary stiffening perpendicular to direction of compression

t p, E are defined in Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.2 Symbols 4.2.1.

4.9 Buckling of primary members

4.9.1 Where primary girders are subject to axial compressive loading, the buckling requirements for lateral, torsional, web and flange buckling modes detailed in Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.7 Secondary stiffening in direction of compression are to be satisfied.

4.9.2 To prevent global buckling from occurring before local panel buckling, transverse primary girders supporting axially loaded longitudinal stiffeners are to have a sectional moment of inertia, including attached plating, of not less than the following:

g = x 103 cm4

S p and s are as defined in Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.2 Symbols 4.2.1, see also Figure 7.4.1 Shear buckling of stiffened panels

g = sectional moment of inertia including attached plating

s = moment of inertia of secondary stiffeners, in cm4, required to satisfy the overall elastic column buckling mode requirement specified in Table 7.4.3 Buckling stress of secondary stiffeners
=
where

σep = 1,2σd N/mm2 for σe(a) <
= for σe(a)

σd is design stress, in N/mm2

σa and A te are as defined in Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.2 Symbols 4.2.1.

σe(a) is the elastic column buckling stress, see Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.7 Secondary stiffening in direction of compression 4.7.2

E is defined in Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.2 Symbols 4.2.1

l e is defined in Table 7.4.3 Buckling stress of secondary stiffeners

4.10 Shear buckling of girder webs

4.10.1 Local panels in girder webs subject to in-plane shear loads are to satisfy the shear buckling requirements in Table 7.4.2 Plate panel buckling requirements, item (b).

4.10.2 The critical shear buckling stress, τc, is to be determined using the following formula for τe and the Note in Table 7.4.1 Buckling stress of plate panels.

τe = 3,62 N/mm2
where
d w = web height, in mm
p = unsupported length of web, in metres

t p and E are defined in Pt 7, Ch 7, 4.2 Symbols 4.2.1.

4.11 Pillars and pillar bulkheads

4.11.1 Pillars and pillar bulkheads are to comply with the requirements of Pt 7, Ch 3, 10 Pillars and pillar bulkheads.


Copyright 2022 Clasifications Register Group Limited, International Maritime Organization, International Labour Organization or Maritime and Coastguard Agency. All rights reserved. Clasifications Register Group Limited, its affiliates and subsidiaries and their respective officers, employees or agents are, individually and collectively, referred to in this clause as 'Clasifications Register'. Clasifications Register assumes no responsibility and shall not be liable to any person for any loss, damage or expense caused by reliance on the information or advice in this document or howsoever provided, unless that person has signed a contract with the relevant Clasifications Register entity for the provision of this information or advice and in that case any responsibility or liability is exclusively on the terms and conditions set out in that contract.